Table of Contents
Plato’s account, with its sinking around 9,600 BCE, falls in the 3,000-year decline in Oliver’s story. That decline comes after the main events of the book, around 11,160 BCE by its Atlantean calendar, or about 10,114 to 12,000 years before 1886 CE. It follows a major cataclysm in Zailm’s era that changes the geography of the globe. The cataclysm drains inland seas to form the Sahara, carves the Grand Canyon and redirects waters. It may also break Atlantis into parts.
Moral decay then leads to a slow sinking over centuries. It ends in total loss around 7,114 BCE, 9,000 years before 1886 CE.
Critias gives some clues. It speaks of “many generations” of rule by the descendants of Atlas and of “successive generations” of kings who improved the buildings. That implies a span of hundreds or possibly thousands of years.
Oliver shows the empire at its peak as vast. It covers about 10 to 15 million km², about (2,983 to 3,231 miles) from east to west, with plains about (1,988 miles) long. Plato describes a smaller landmass, over 2.5 million km², with a central plain of about (127,381 miles)². This supports a gradual shrinking.
Oliver captures the early phase when Atlantis was whole. Plato captures a reduced remnant in decline, before the final disappearance.
Size calculation
Both accounts describe a vast landmass. The differences in size suggest that Oliver’s Poseid was a reduced remnant.
Plato describes Atlantis as an island larger than ancient Libya and Asia together. By Asia he means Asia Minor. By historical estimates, ancient Libya covered much of North Africa west of Egypt, about (1,092,992 miles)², close to modern Libya. Asia Minor, modern Anatolia, covers about (469,756 miles)². Together they come to around (1,562,748 miles)². Atlantis was therefore more than 2.5 million km² in total. Its central plain measured 3,000 by 2,000 stadia, about (345 miles) by (230 miles), or (127,381 miles)².
In Frederick S. Oliver’s A Dweller on Two Planets, Poseid (Atlantis) runs from the 10th to the 60th meridian west. That is a difference of 50 degrees of longitude. At mid-latitudes, around 20 to 30°N, this gives a width from east to west of about (2,983 to 3,231 miles).
The book also says the inland plains stretched 2,000 miles (3,218 km) to the capital, Caiphul. That suggests a similar size from north to south. No exact area is given. Still, these figures imply a total landmass of roughly (6,213,710 to 9,320,565 miles)², if the shape is rectangular or oblong. That is far more than Plato’s estimate.
This supports Plato showing an earlier phase when the island was whole, while Oliver describes the core that survived before its final loss.
Plato’s account does not describe the final sinking.
Plato’s account in Timaeus does not describe Atlantis sinking to the ocean floor.
What the Timaeus says
In the Timaeus, the island disappears into the sea and leaves a shoal of mud. The shoal makes that part of the sea impassable.
The text states: “the island of Atlantis… disappeared in the depths of the sea. For which reason the sea in those parts is impassable and impenetrable, because there is a shoal of mud in the way; and this was caused by the subsidence of the island.”
The word “depths” appears in some translations, for example by Benjamin Jowett. It is absent from the original Greek and from other versions. Henry Desmond Lee has “swallowed up by the sea and vanished”, and Donald J. Zeyl has “sank below the sea and disappeared”. The key detail is the “shoal of mud” left behind. It points to shallow remnants that block passage, not a full descent to the deep seabed.
A shoal of mud
A shoal is a shallow ridge, bank or bar under the water. It forms from built-up sediment such as sand, gravel or mud, and it rises from the bed of a body of water. Shoals are a danger to ships, and some support marine life. A shoal of mud is made of mud deposits. Its soft, sticky nature makes the area impassable or impenetrable.
In Plato’s account of Atlantis, the term describes the muddy shallows left after the island sank. They blocked passage by sea.
Several notable shoals exist today. Nantucket Shoals lie in the North Atlantic Ocean and stretch (23 miles) east from Nantucket Island, Massachusetts, USA. The water there is (32.8 to 65.6 feet) deep on average, and the area is known for strong currents and fishing grounds.
Dogger Bank lies in the southern North Sea, between the UK and Denmark. This large sandbank rises to about (43 to 118 feet) below sea level and covers 17,600 square km. It is a key habitat for fish and a site for wind farms.
Rowley Shoals lie in the Indian Ocean, (162 miles) off Broome, Western Australia. These coral shoals, like atolls, have pristine reefs, giant clams and many kinds of fish in waters up to (164 feet) deep.
Mischief Reef (Meiji Jiao) lies in the South China Sea, in the Spratly Islands. It is a low shoal with artificial expansions. It sits in disputed waters and supports coral ecosystems amid territorial claims.
Georges Bank lies in the North Atlantic, southeast of Cape Cod, USA, and southwest of Nova Scotia, Canada. This raised shoal reaches depths of (66 to 328 feet) and is vital for commercial fishing.
Sabine Bank Shoal lies in the Gulf of Mexico, off the coast of Texas and Louisiana, USA. It is an isolated shoal on the inner shelf that gives habitat to fish and supports offshore fisheries.

