Xenophon

A sketch of Xenophon’s life

A sketch of Xenophon's lifeXenophonpostXenophonBooksGreekPersianBabylonBooks Greek Persian Babylon.babel

Book contents. Previous: Introductory remarks and notes. Next: Anabasis, Book I.

A SKETCH OF XENOPHON’S LIFE

circa 431, Birth. — (The first year of the Pdoponnesian War. )

I 43Z-424, Infancy ((ut. 1-7). — Till the eighth year of the war, his Ufe

was probably spent in Athens, at any rate during spring ^^ and summer.

423-415, Boyhood {aet. 8-16). — Spent possibly partly in the country (at I Erchia, modem Spata) ; religious training t^ Tarfdtp vdfjup

(Anab. VII. viii. 5, see below, p. 315) ; old -Attic vocabu- ^ lary ; education in fiov(riK^ ypdfifiara yvfipaamci^ ; gnomic ;

sophistic ; may have ’ ’ heard ” Prodicus of Ceos ; introduction

to Socrates.

415-413, Youth {aet 16-18). — Socratic training, illustrated hy Memorab,, Symp.t Oeconom.

^ 413-41 1 (a^/. 18-20). — Hunting education, illustrated by Cv»^^(f/«Vtf.

S 411-405 (a^/. 20-26). — Political interests, illustrated by /^(f/Z?/t/ra, I. and

II. (A).

I 405-403, Young Manhood (aet, 26-28). — N.B, There are two conversa-

tions in Mem. (II. viii., vii.), named as belonging respectively to the end of the war, 405 B.C., and the ‘*year of anarchy,” 404-403.

403-401 (aet. 28-30). — Political prospects, from the amnesty to Cyreian

expedition. Cynegetica possibly published now ; and the

portion of HelUnica^ I.- II. iii. 10 (see below, pp. 1-50 ;

^ also note on Hellenica\ constituting the va.ptxK^.vl>\i/evo. or

sequel to Thucydides, being got ready for publication.

401-399, Manhood [aet, 30-32). — Floruit; the advance with Cyrus and

the retreat of the Ten Thousand ; the Thracian campaign ;

^ surrender of the remnant of the Cyreians, six thousand men,

to Thibron ; illustrated by Anab. and Cyrop.t also Hell,

III. (B).

I 399-394 {^^* 32-37). — Uncertain movements at this date (spring of

\ 399 B.C.) ; Hell. I. and II. (A) published (?) ; Asiatic cam-

paigns with Spartan harmosts, Thibron (?), Dercylidas, I Agesilaus ; marriage ; exile ; sons ; return to Europe,

394 B.C. before Coronea ; illustrated by Hell. III. iv. (B).

B.C.

394-387 (aet, 37-44). — ^With Agesilaus in Sparta and campaigning (?) ; sons educated in Spartan training ; till perhaps peace of Antalcidas (?) ; illustrated by Hell. IV. v. 1-36 (B) ; and Lac, Pol,

387-371, Middle Age (aet, 44-60). — Presented (now or perhaps earlier, 389 B.C.) by Spartan authorities, with a house and farm at Scillus, where he resides for many years, acting probably as proxenus for his adopted state ; intellectual floruit, great literary period ; illustrated by all his writings in some form or other. Many, e.g. Memor., Symp,^ Oeconom.^ Hiero, were here published ; the material for the remaining portions of the Hellenica was being got together currente calamo; and material for later works, some of which were nearly ready for publication, e.g. Anabasis, revised.

371-369 (aet. 60-62). — Battle of Leuctra ; the Anabasis published after expulsion from Scillus, and Hellenica B (=^Hell, II. iii. 11 — V. i. 36), perhaps in the year 371 B.C., after Leuctra, possibly at Corinth, where the family finally settled. The sons going back to Athens after the decree of banishment was rescinded, probably in 369 B.a, served in the Athenian cavalry at Mantinea 362 B.C.

369-362 {aet. 62-69). — Banishment rescinded; literary labours continued at Corinth (or possibly at times at Athens) ; Hipparchikos (or a Cavalry General’s Manual), with its sequel the irep^ XicTciKyfi (tract on Horsemanship), both published ; the Cyropaedia and Hellenica C ( — Hell. V. ii. to end) put into shape and finally published between 365 and 357 B.C. (epilogue to Cyrop. after 364) ; death of Gryllus before Mantinea 362 B.C.

362-354, Old Age (aet. 69-77). — His last work, the II6/mk, or tract on Revenues, pubUshed 355 B.C.

circa 354, Death (^/. 77). — He died at Corinth (tradition sa)rs); s&& Demetr,

Magn., ap. Diog. Laert. Life of Xenophon,

J2d

a’, a: as

at

s

“THE SAGE AND HEROIC XENOPHON.”— Gibbon.

’ ’ Life may as properly be called an art as any other ; and the great incidents in it are no more to be considered as mere accidents, than the several members of a fine statue or a noble poem.” — Fielding.

Boyhood and Early Manhood, 431-401 b.c. ; Infancy, 431-424 ; Boyhood, 423-415 ; Youth, 415-405 : Young Manhood, 405-401 b.c.

Xenophon was an Athenian, of the deme (or borough town) Erchia, and therefore a fellow – townsman of his illustrious contemporary Isocrates. His father was named Gryllus, his mother probably Diodora.^ By his own marriage he had two sons, Niamed respectively Gryllus and Diodorus. They were famousNin their day, and were popularly called the Dioscuri, or great^^win brethren. Possibly they were twins. But of them presently.

The date of Xenophon’s birth is, as above explained, uncertain. For the purpose of this sketch it is assumed that he was bom about the commencement of the Peloponnesian war in 431 B.C. (possibly a little earlier; not improbably even somewhat later).

With regard to his early bringing -up, the status of his family, the means and occupation of his father, we know next to nothing. It is commonly believed that Xenophon was qualified to serve as a knight. Tradition ^ says that he did so serve. He had all the tastes of an Athenian country gentleman or yeoman, of the type presented to us by his own Ischomachus,^ devoted to dogs and horses, and the breeding

^ See Roquette, de Vit. Xen., Append. II., “de Xen. Matre,” p. 109 foll. ^ Diog. Laert. ii. 5, Vit, Socr. 7 ; Strabo, IX. ii. 7. * See Oecon, vi. 17.

and training of these, and to hunting as a preliminary to warfare.^ He took horses with him on the famous expedition under Cyrus; and it was he who, at a critical moment,^ organised the small squadron of forty horse, which proved so effective during the retreat. His interest in this branch of the service is unceasing, and is evident in many passages of his works. As an old campaigner he seems to have taken to tTTTTtKov under his special protection, and he ended by writing two companion treatises on the subject, the earlier of which, ” A General of Cavalry,” is addressed apparently to one of the hipparchs for the year at Athens — ^possibly about 365 B.C. — when his two sons were serving as knights in the state cavalry. If this was the status of the family, we may suppose that his parents had means ; and it is clear * that Xenophon set off on the expedition above named in quest of glory and adventure rather than of wealth. The question, as we shall see, is important in reference rather to his political leanings than to his economical surroundings.

We may, perhaps, assume that the boy was reared in easy circumstances and as befitted a KaXos re /cdya^os,* a ” beautiful and good ” citizen of Athens. We may assume further that he was piously and healthily brought up. The grown man, we know, was religiously and healthily disposed ; ^ and the child, we suspect, was herein father to the man. But we have also a suggestive anecdote which throws light on the family worship in the home of Xenophon in the rural deme of Erchia. It is recounted on page 315 of this volume, and I need not repeat it ; but it is noticeable that Zeus Meilichios^ to whom the old family soothsayer Eucleides bids Xenophon sacrifice ” in the ancestral fashion,” is the same god who was honoured in the festival of the Diasia ; ^ and the incident may

1 Cf. de R. Eq. ^ See below, p. 161 foll.

3 See below, pp. 249, 259.

  • See Becker, Charicles, Excursus to § i, “Education.”

” See Diog. Laert.»Z,^ of Ken, ; Anab. passim.

^ The Diasia was a country festival existent long before the festival of Olympic Zeus, as Cylon in his attempt upon the Acropolis found out to his cost. And, to iskip from grave to gay, the name recalls not only the tragic end of Cylon, but the tragico – comical experiences of the old Athenian country gentleman in the play {Aristoph. Clouds^ 408 foll. , 864) trying to soften the obdurate heart of his hoi’se-racing youngster by reminding him how, when he

even throw a ray of light on the old-Attic propensities (etymological or other) of our author.

We may further surmise that the health of his body was no less thought of than that 6f his soul. The love of field exercises and the chase, the belief in bodily training and the salutary effects of toil, summed up in one of his mottoes ovScv avev ISp&ros, date back to childhood.

If he was born in 431 b.c. and was in Attica at all, the first years of his life, or a great part of each year, must have been spent inside the city walls. The distances in that whole country are indeed so small that the owner of an estate even at Thoricus might have returned to his farm at intervals after the Laconian troops had done their work of devastation for one year, and before they returned on the same errand the next, so that the child may well have breathed fresh air during some months in every year.^

He gives no hint, nor indeed had he perhaps any vivid recollection, of the earlier troubles incidental to the “Archidamic ” war. He is equally silent touching things which he might well haVe recollected as he grew in years. As far as

was a little boy and could only lisp; his father had bought him a little go-cart at the festival of the Diasia. Strepsiades, the father, bears no further resemblance to Gryllus than that he is an old man from the country ; nor, except in his love for horses, does Pheidippides recall Xenophon. (He is more like a famous Athenian, with whom Xenophon has been sometimes confounded, Alcibiades. ) But, for the peep into Attic life which it affords, with its contrasts of old and new, rustic and polite, during the age of the Sophists, the whole play is an apt commentary upon the times of Xenophon’s boyhood.

The anecdote of the Anabasis is suggestive not only of a religious but of an old-fashioned style of bringing-up ; and, if I am not mistaken, even the phraseology of Xenophon bears an impress also of that ancient style of education so much commended by the Dikaios Logos in the play already referred to. How is it that Xenophon is so glib in the use of old Attic words and inflections ? why is it a chance whether he will say weircurBai or K€icTTj<T0ai» and why does he persist in writing peK^wv, 6pi<av, etc. ? Why does he call the goddess of dawn *Hwj as the poets do, and not “Ews as the rest of the world does ? I know that there are other answers to the question, but I cannot help thinking that it is because, at an age at which the boy could only lisp, such were the sounds familiar to his ears in his father’s family, and amongst the peasantry on the eastward face of Brilessus (Pentelicus), in the rural d^me of EJTchia.

  • It was no great distance from Athens to Erchia (i\ot nearly so far as to Thoricus) if, as is supposed, the site of the ddme is that of the modem Spata. By the modem road it cannot be more than (27.4 or 29 kilometers). See map.

foreign invasions were concerned, his out-door training might well have begun in earnest at the age of seven (the eighth year of the war), 424 ac, and have been continued steadily till the first year of the “Deceleian” war, 413 b.c, when he would be eighteen years of age. Then for ten years it must have ceased entirely, or nearly so. In his tract on hunting (which as some think was his earUest work) ^ he says in a style somewhat pedagogic for so youthful a writer : ” My advice to the young is, do not despise hunting or the other training of .your boyhood, if you wish to grow up to be good men, good not only in war, but in all else of which the issue is perfection in thought, word, and deed.” And before plunging into practical details, he adds : ” The first efforts of a youth emerging from boyhood should be directed to the institution of the chase ; after which he should come to the rest of education — ^provided he have the means and with an eye to the same ; if his means be ample, in a style worthy of the profit to be derived ; or, if they be scant, let him at any rate contribute enthusiasm, in nothing falling short of the power he possesses.”

Whether he himself enjoyed this education, or is only inculcating what he regarded as desirable, and was able eventually to give to his own sons at the proper time of life, we cannot say. What we can say is that his description of the chase in this treatise (as far as coursing hares is concerned) would suit the slopes and gullies of the Attic mountains (of Fames, Pentelicus, and Hymettus) no less than the scenery of the Triphylia, of Pholoe and the hills which stand about Olympia.

Apart, however, from this exceptional form of gymnastic, and provided always that his boyhood ^ was spent in Attica and Athens, we may suppose that he was subjected to the common training of young Athenians at that time. “We have been companions in the chorus, the school, the army,” is the telling appeal with which the herald of the miistai^ Cleocritus, challenges the city party on a memorable occasion to cease strife with the exiles in Piraeus.^ We may picture Xenophon as a

^ See Cyneg, i. 18 ; ii. i. If this was really an early work, I think it must have been re-handled and re-edited in middle age. See below.

  • See a story in Philostratus, Vit. Soph. i. 12, according to which he lived part of the time as a captive in Boeotia. ^ See below, p. 68.

boy sharing in choruses, or wending his way to school, or going through the exercises of the palaestra and gymnasium with the Critobuluses and Euthydemuses, who were his fellows, just as when older he probably shared in military drill and service — whether with horse or shield — and in the first instance perhaps among the TrepCiroXoiJ- At school he would learn ypdfAfiara and fiovo’LK’q and yvfivcuTTiKrjf according to the system in vogue. He would come to know the poets — Theognis and Hesiod and Epicharmus — and, beyond all, Homer. In all ways he was brought up, I think, in the ancient style, as far as was then possible, and whatever else was the result of this education, the main point was secured. The young man had formed in his breast the image of Aidos. For the rest his training in the new learning of the Sophists was, for a youth of his temperament, by no means detrimental. Rather it was of the best. It is quite possible that, like Callias or Proxenus,^ he paid fees to some one of the professors to whom he introduces us in the Memorabilia and elsewhere. Perhaps Dionysodorus taught him tactics. Perhaps he heard Prodicus of Ceos. But it was a greater than Prodicus who truly initiated him into such philosophy as he was capable of, and who taught him how to discover the first principles not of strategics only but of a much higher art — that of right living — and of icaAo- KayaSia in general. This teacher, himself the greatest of the Sophists, and yet in a deep sense antagonistic to all other professors of wisdom — one also to whom he certainly paid no fees of money — it need hardly be said, was Socrates.

At what age Xenophon came under the influence of this friend and teacher, we cannot tell ; we may suppose, however, that he was emerging from boyhood, and had done with paidagogoiy in the technical sense, when this new and spiritualising influence was brought to bear upon him. If we are to guess at a date, we might choose that famous year 415 b.c. (the seventeenth of the war), in which the expedition sailed for Sicily, and Alcibiades, being accused of profaning the mysteries, was condemned to death in his absence. Socrates himself

^ A sort of horse patrol composed of young Athenians between eighteen and twenty to guard tfie frontier.

’^ See Symp, v. 4, 62 ; Anab. V. vi. 16, p. 141 ; Mem, III. i. i, II. i. 21.

would then have been fifty-three, Plato would have been fourteen, Alcibiades about thirty-four, and Xenophon about sixteen. Whenever it happened and however the introduction came about, the change wrought in the young man’s disposition was deep and permanent. The story is prettily told by Diogenes Laertius, and with so clear a ring of poetic truth that we need not stay to inquire whether the particular incident occurred. This is how the biographer recounts the matter: “Xenophon was modest of mien, and surpassingly fair to look upon. Tradition tells how Socrates met him in a narrow way, and stretching his staff athwart him, so as to bar his passage, plied him with inquiries as to where this or that commodity was to be purchased, to all which questions the boy answered fluently ; when the sage at length put to him a final question, *And where are the fair and noble to be found ? ’ The boy shook his head ^ in perplexity. Then said he, ‘Follow me, and be taught’ So he followed him, and thereafter became his hearer, ^^’^

The question so propounded became indeed the problem of Xenophon’s life. Where are the KaAot KayaSoi to be found ? And what is that perfection of combined beauty and goodness, displaying itself in beautiful and good deeds, otherwise called virtue? That to some extent he solved it will perhaps be admitted by whoever has noted the distinctive quality of his writings and the persistent ambition of his life. The answer which the “inspirer” himself was prepared to give to his “hearer” may in part be read in the Recollections and other “Socratic” writings of Xenophon; and still more largely in the dialogues of Plato. The attitude meanwhile of the pupil to his friend during ten or fifteen years of his life is easy to picture.^

^ Lit. ” raised his brows,” precisely as a modern Greek does, expressing blank surprise. 2 Dj^g^ L^ert. Life, § 2.

’ It has indeed been pictorially represented by that most famous painter of the Renaissance, whose sympathetic mind unerringly interpreted to him the spirit of the Greeks. In Rafael’s School of Athens, among the six or seven figures which compose the Socratic group, that of Socrates himself is so truly depicted as to form a companion to the portrait of the philosopher as drawn by Alcibiades in the Symposium of Plato. Of the rest, none are more truthful to the imagination than those of Alcibiades and Xenophon. The helmeted mail-clad warrior facing the philosopher with exquisite proud poise, indicative of a graceful

The best commentary on this period of Xenophon’s life is to be found in his own Socratic writings, and chiefly in the Memorabilia. That work is an honest attempt to explain the character and position of Socrates to a public who seemed to misconceive of him ; and, being based mainly on the writer’s personal recollections, is replete with autobiographic matter. It must be borne in mind, however, that none of these writings were published, nor in any technical sense composed, until long after the death of Socrates, which took place in 399 b.c. Even the most matter-of-fact of them, therefore, the Memorabilia^ cannot escape a certain colouring. Socrates is seen through a vista of years. The young man’s memoranda, however faithfully preserved, represent also the mature reflections of one who has himself gone through many experiences, since as a youth he sat in some saddler’s shop and imbibed words of wisdom, and whose own character is formed. With this caution we may well turn over the pages of the Memorabilia^ etc., in confidence that the story of Xenophon’s own deeper education lies therein. There is, indeed, one specially autobiographic passage,^ in which the author names himself as an interlocutor in a conversation (which took place between Socrates and Critobulus), the subject of which may be called “the danger of a kiss.” Possibly Socrates had observed in Xenophon a certain propensity, which in his ironic fashion he thus set himself to counteract. The incident appears to have clung to the mind of him whose judgment was appealed to.

Besides this, there are endless occasions on which Xenophon suggests his own presence at a conversation by such phrases as, ” I will here mention what I once heard him say about the divine power ; ” ^ qj.^ « ^s I listened to these sayings I could not but reflect that he himself had attained, whilst we his hearers were being led onwards, to true happiness ; ” ® or again, in order to show how Socrates helped his friends out of

self-confidence on the very verge of insolence, is unmistakable ; but beside the latter, with back-turned face, hanging on his lips, is a youth with rosy cheeks and auburn hair ; he leans on one arm in a brooding attitude ; his eyes are set in deep, earnest, religious gaze. That is Xenophon, the future apologist of the life of Socrates, treasuring one of the discussions of the Memorabilia,

^ Mem. I. iii. 12. ’ lb. I. iv. 2.

’ lb. I. vi. 14 ; cf. I. vii. 5 ; II. i. i, iv. 1, v. i, vi. 1.

their difficulties, varying the treatment to suit the need of the case, he recounts three or four stories, ” which he can personally vouch for’* (c/Dw 5c koI kv rovrots a o^voiha avry).^ The two first of these are, it so happens, the only two in the whole collection of which the exact date is given in so many words — the one is named as belonging to the end of the war 405 ac, and the other to the year of division which followed — ^before the city party and the party of Piraeus had healed their differences.^ To others we can approximately assign the date through internal evidence; some are dateless. But our suspicion is that the mass of these conversations which Xenophon recounts on his personal authority belong to his maturity, say to the years 411 b.c. and onwards.

By that date (411 b.c) Xenophon had doubtless begun to take an interest in politics (as what Athenian did not ?), and was perhaps meditating some essay in literature. The prospect of continuing the history of Thucydides had not as yet dawned upon him ; nor could he as yet foresee the need which would come of writing an apology for Socrates. But I make no doubt that he already had an eye to current affairs ; and in the spirit of Boswell was duly taking notes of conversations which he felt to be of permanent interest.

It may be hard at times, as already suggested, to distinguish between the later reflections of the middle-aged man of letters and the original impressions of curious youth ; but the fact remains incontestable that this was the period of seedtime. The particular word or words in which the good seed was sown ; the exact moment (to use a more Socratic phrase) at which birth was given to some struggling idea, we may not be able to discover ; but we have Xenophon’s own testimony to the educational effect of this discourse or that discussion upon the minds of those who, like himself, consorted with Socrates, and we can hardly doubt that he was generalising from his own experience. If he says that to listen to such and such remarks was to be led on a step farther in the direction of KaXoKayaOiOj or self-restraint, or wisdom, or courage, or trust in the Gods, or belief in the omnipresence of Divinity, or acquiescence in the supreme will, he means that he himself

^ Mem, II. vii., viii., ix., x. i. ^ gee below, p. 65 foll.

must admit that in his experience it was so ; and hence it is

with a genuine outburst of affection, betokening a deep sense

of his own indebtedness and loss that he speaks of the very ! recollection of Socrates as in itself an inspiration to good

conduct. ” Amongst those who were brought into communion > with Socrates and recognised his greatness, all true lovers of

virtue still to this day cease not to lament his incomparable f loss with bitterest regret ; as for one who, as none else could,

helped them in the pursuit of perfection. For my part, when

I think of him and what he was like . . ”^

The qualities which he admired most in Socrates were his I spirituality ; his faith and sense of proportion in matters divine ^ and matters temporal; his sincerity and independence; his ! horror of quackery and self-deceit ; his educational ardour in

behalf of all who consorted with him ; the purity of his aim I and methods ; his enthusiasm in the service of the world at

large ; his subordination of all virtues, whether of the intellectual I or of the practical type, to healthiness of soul (a-ii}p(xrvvri),^

Further to point what has been said. The biographical,

that is to say, the autobiographical importance, in a general i^ sense, of the Memorabilia (as of the other Socratic writings of i Xenophon), can hardly be exaggerated; but there is need S of discrimination before we can say that such and such a

conversation throws light upon the youth and early manhood

of Xenophon. Thus, if we consider the nature of the dis-

\ ^ See Mem, IV. viii. ii foll.

  • Some of the good words now sown, which were destined to bear fruit

L eventually, may readily be picked out. They recur frequently in the writings

of Xenophon. They are his adopted formulae — one might speak of them

’ as talismans. Such is the Hesiodic gnome Kadd^fpafiw to which Socrates gave

1^ new currency ; or the Xenophontine motto, v Qeois ; or this : dirb rQv

QeQp &pX’£<fBiu. Some are t^ts of the spirit, suited to self-examination, such

as : * ’ Be what you would fain be thought to be ” ; or this, ” What am I worth

to my friend ? ” Others are compendious moral maxims : ’ ’ Self-mastery is

, the kelson of virtue ; ” *’ Virtues grow by knowledge (and practice).” One is

f the master’s own prayer, and the pupil did well to remember it. “Give me

1^ what is best for me, for ye know what good things are.” — Mem. I. iii. s ; of.

  • Plat. Alcib. ii. 143 A —

Zee pcurikcO, rd fih iadXii. koX e^o/u^vois Koi AveiicTOis

• • O King Zeus, grant to us all blessings, whether we pray for them or not, And deliver us from evil, even to the denial of our prayers.”

cussions themselves, some, it must be admitted, savour somewhat of the after-reflection of a mature commentator ; and from a biographical point of view are no less illustrative of the veteran at Scillus than of the young man at Athens. Such is a series in Mem, II. on the relations of parents and children. ” How should a son behave to his mother ? ” or ” Concerning brotherly affection.” But these are just of a sort to mark the intimate relations between the teacher and the pupil at the time. They form a chapter of the private life of Socrates revealed to a friend. There is no reason why they should not be also verbatim reports at first hand. Others read like authentic records of actual descriptions related to Xenophon by an intimate friend. The two conversations between Euthydemus and Socrates in Bk. IV. are good specimens. Another set suggest either that Xenophon himself, or some one very like Xenophon, was the interlocutor. The sentiments of the disputant might well have been his at the time. Such are the two in Bk. HI. ch. ii. and iii. — Socrates and a young man on the duties and ambition of a strategos and of a hipparch respectively. (We are close upon autobiography here, I think.) Others, again, discover the artist working up his material to the best advantage (and occasionally perhaps in a way which offends our sense of dramatic propriety). How often is not Xenophon tempted consciously or unconsciously to impress his own personality upon some one or other of his dramatis personae? There is a final class, of which the Economist may be taken as a highly -developed type, which read as if the artist had at times got the better of the biographer. It is hard not to believe that in the conversation between Socrates and Pericles the younger (one of the unfortunate generals at Arginusae, it will be recollected), Xenophon has contrived dramatically to represent the workings of his own mind upon the subject of debate. Just as the Economist is perhaps an expansion of some actual Socratic conversation with a view to a freer handling of the topic, so this particular discussion (setting forth the pessimistic views of Pericles concerning the Athens of the moment, in contrast with the more hopeful views of Socrates touching an ideal Athens of the future) might well have been worked up into

a political pamphlet in praise of the Solonian institutions.* Between these two voices it is possible to detect the workings of Xenophon’s own mind. One may hear or overhear his thoughts excusing or else accusing one another politically. Such a discussion may actually have taken place — ^and Xenophon may have listened to it probably between 411 ac. and 406 B.C., by which time his own miso-Theban views ‘were probably already pronounced.

But it was not to Socrates alone that Xenophon’s introduction to politics was due (though to make his friends statesmanlike was, as we know, a great object with that teacher) ; there were other go-betweens of all sorts, human or metaphysical. Demonic forces were leading him on, and fixing his views for better or for worse. These were pre-eminently the current incidents of the time (some of which he has graphically enough described). There were also the prepossessions and intellectual propensities of the individual. What Xenophon’s leanings were we can scarcely doubt. He is one of those thinkers to whom we may perhaps apply the modem term “aristocratic” without doing his departed spirit an injustice.^ In the arena of ancient politics he watches impartially the behaviour of the combatants in their strife for glory ; but his eye is fixed most readily on the doings of the ^kXrurroi, whether the state be friendly or hostile. The better classes were better than the rest of the world. That is axiomatic ; at the same time he admits Socratically the sad truth : CorrupHo optimi pessima est Nor does his admiration of respectability fill him with prejudices against the vavrticos oxAos of Piraeus, whose good discipline on shipboard delights him. It does not blind him to the fact that in a deeper and more philosophic sense the free man may be a very slave in soul and the slave-born man win to himself a patent of nobility. But, on the whole, and with large

1 Such a treatise would have been an apt counterpart of the so-called Laconian Polity^ a pamplet in praise of the institutions of Lycurgus.. As to the Athenian Polity see above. It was written by perhaps a cleverer, at any rate a more Machiavelian, person than Xenophon.

3 Could he revisit earth an^ study modem literature, I think he would find the doctrines of Thomas Carlyle most congenial to his political mind ; but to his aesthetic and philosophic soul in general the style and sentiments of John Ruskin.

deductions due no less to his human-heartedness than to his artistic sense (to which, as to some high court of equity, he may appeal against the prejudices of an Athenian knight or hoplite), he is of the school at Athens of Theramenes.^

What part, if any, the future historian of the period himself played in public affairs from 411 b.c. to the date of the amnesty, whether or not he shared in the troubles of the Four Hundred or in those of the Thirty, we cannot say. It is quite possible that, in accordance with a tradition mentioned by Philostratus, he was during part of this time a prisoner in Boeotia. Wherever he was, it is certain that his political views were all the while shaping themselves. If merely from a literary and artistic point of view, he could not fail to note with curiosity the course of events, the import of which, whether at home or abroad, was alike momentous. The plot thickened apace. The spectator was not of a temperament to sit by perfectly unmoved, or unbiassed in his judgment. Perhaps, like the youthful Ion in the play of Euripides, he wished to hold himself aloof, iv TrdAct ^d<^v ^Xc^^ But however loath he might be to plunge into affairs at the sacrifice of that ” dearest boon to mortals — ^leisure,” he was at the same time a youth of some ambition. He had studied to make himself an adept in speech and action. The question must ere long present itself to his mind, How was he to turn his political training to account ?

On the whole, and apart from the dramatic interest of them, the incidents of these years offered no encouraging prospect to

^ So, after Mr. W. L. Newman {The Politics of Aristotle, vol. i. p. 491), I name the more moderate wing of the popular party at Athens dming the years 411-403 B.C. (see Thuc. viii. 97, and Xen. Hell, II. iii. 43, p. 60 below, and note 4). For the doctrines of this ’ ’ left centre ” party, with many of which Aristotle himself sympathised, see op. cit. p. 470 foil They may be summed up in the phrase ^ did r(a» fukciov iroXfreta : and by the /x^croi we must understand the moderately well-to-do classes in the state intermediate between the very rich and the very poor. Another • • left centre ” tenet attributed to Theramenes is that the well-wishers of a constitution must be stronger than its opponents if the constitution is to stand, op, cit, p. 491 and note ; see also Xen. Hell, II. iii. 19, 20, 42, 44, compared with Aristot. Pol, 7(5)9, 1309 h. 16 seq, ; 8(6)6 1320 b, 25 seq. The above seems ^fair conclusion to draw from the tone of the first two books of the Hellenica.

’ See Eur. Ion, 601, and with the boy’s speech, cf. Xen. Mem, III. vii. 5 and Cyrop. I. ii. 3.

a man of his disposition. There were the events of 411 B.a The government of the Five Thousand might perhaps have satisfied him, could it have lasted.^ In that best of modem constitutions, in which oligarchy and democracy were duly attempered, and the reins of power lay in the hands of those who could furnish themselves with arms, Xenophon might have hoped at the age of thirty to find a sphere of usefulness. But the limited democracy did not last for more than one year. Again in the spring of 404 b.c. could the young philosopher have stopped the wheels of time, just when the Thirty commissioners were chosen to draft a constitution based on the ancestral laws of the state ; could he have forced them to carry out the duty imposed on them, we can readily imagine the type of polity which he would have had established. As a matter of fact the commissioners had no intention of setting up a Neo-Solonian democracy, nor yet an aristocracy; they were bent upon the methods of tyranny. Yet even so their first high-handed measures against ‘sycophants’ might perhaps be winked at, but the introduction of a Laconian bodyguard under a creature like Callibius was past forgiveness. Xenophon would have been no true pupil of Socrates if his horror of sycophancy and the make-believe of statecraft had not been counterbalanced by an instinctive repugnance to tyranny and lawlessness. Some of these commissioners might have possessed the rudiments at least of political sagacity — they were not simply empirics ; but unless they added to these elements the right moral diathesis which distinguishes the true ruler, they had not the €Trurrrjfi7j of government, their technical knowledge was in vain. Critias might be the fit subject of a moral treatise : corruptio optimt\ but he was no true governor. Where then was stable government to be found? Not in democratic Athens, where the voter was ignorant and government depended on the lottery of the bean. Was it perchance to be found in Sparta ? or was Xenophon rather indulging a philosophic dream of a liew Athens, a novel association of states in a renovated Hellas, in which the naturally cohesive force of virtue should as by some elective affinity bind to-

^ See Thuc. vii. 97.

gether the souls of the ilite ; where there should be an ideal combination of all the KaXoKayadoi in the state, or in society at large, to help each other, and in generous rivalry to dominate and regenerate the world ? Was not that the meaning of what Socrates had been saying to Critobulus about friendship?^ Thus he ruminated.

But how was his own tXjoTLfiia to express itself? One may easily make a grave blunder in answering such a question touching a man in whom the artist ever predominated over the citizen. If we may judge from hints scattered up and down his writings, or from the analogy of other young Athenians at the time (one thinks of Proxenus as described by Xenophon himself, of Mantitheus in the speech of Lysias, of Alcibiades as depicted in the Alcid, major of Plato) ; or lastly, from the next chapter of his own life, as narrated in the Anabasis^ he took a supreme interest in the problem of a/ox’?^ I^ ^^ could not rule in his own person he would like to divine the secret of rule, and to discover the ” archie ” man. His moralising habit of mind, moreover, led him to divide the world into good and bad, or to accept with readiness the old political party catchwords.^ For some reason the popular party at Thebes, whose scheme was to absorb the other Boeotian states, appears to him in an evil light. Even after the restoration and in spite of the good turn th^ did to the exiles, he cannot get over his natural antipathy to this border state; and amid the home troubles he could not help being driven to certain generalisations. In these lie the germs of the political philosophy of the mature man.

These speculations, which had occupied his mind for half a dozen years, were rudely interrupted by the anarchy of the Thirty. Presently we are in the turmoil of civil war. What, if he was at Athens, was the occupation of Xenophon

^ See Mem. II. vi. ’ See Index “Xenophon.”

^ Theognis, 31-38; cf. Mem. I. ii. 20; Plato, Meno, 95 D; Aristot. Eth. ix. 9 ; and see Mr. Symonds’ remarks on the meaning of i(rd(A and ii.ya.d6Lt KaKol and SeiXd (Greek Poets, i. p. 89).

  • As seen in his reflections on the Laconian or Lycurgean institutions or the ideal oligarchy ; the despotic man ; the archie man. These form the theses of three existing works. The work on the Solonian institutions — which he might have written — was never achieved. Perhaps this was a matter too close home.

then ? We should like very much to know whether he was employed in the cavalry or otherwise, and how he comported himself. His sympathies as a historian seem to be with Thrasybulus. But on the whole we are most struck by the healthy impartiality of the narrative, the chief defect of which j> is that it omits to tell us all we should like to know. The author seems to draw a long breath of relief at the end of Bk. II. ch. iv., ” The Amnesty.” In his own writings there is a gap between the second and third books of the Hellenicay commonly so called, which is only partially covered by the incidents of the Anabasis,

We are led to ask ourselves, what happened to Xenophon in this interval — between the summer of 403 b.c and the spring of 401 B.C. At that latter date we know that he had ^ taken a momentous resolution, and had started on an advenj turous quest with his old friend Proxenus, and his country’s

ancient enemy, the younger Cyrus. In taking this step he was not free from misgivings, if only because he acted against the better judgment of the friend whom he most trusted. What put him to it ? In the absence of real information we are once more thrown back upon conjecture. The explanation, if we can divine it, lies in the character and ambition of the man. Many things perhaps combined at this date to make the invitation of Proxenus attractive : the promptings of his physical temperament, his belief in energising, his political bias and curiosity (since Cyrus was reported to be an ” archie ” man), his somewhat vague but at the same time noble yearnings after reputation — these on the positive side; and on the negative, a sense perhaps of limitation at home, unless he were to strike out a new line of his own. He was not, we suspect, enough of a student to sit down quietly and work out his literary salvation in the closet (as did his contemporary Isocrates). He was not so essentially a soldier that he would have accepted the career of an Iphicrates or a Timotheus had such a chance come in his way. Perhaps he reasoned with himself that just now he had a right to indulge his natural appetite for adventure. It was an appropriate moment at which “to cross over to Asia and meddle with Asiatic affairs,”^

^ See Plato, Alcib. I. 105.

since at this juncture the interests of Sparta and the new democracy were one ; and if the voice of conscience whispered, ” But Cyrus is the arch-enemy of your state,” he might have said to himself, “It is an old story now,” dXXa rot fih tt/ootcrux^at. But it was the touch of knight-errantry in his composition, probably, which, combining with friendship for a friend, enabled him to connive at the antecedents of Cyrus.^

Manhood, 401-387 b.c. ; The “Anabasis,” etc., 401-399 b.c. ; Uncertain Movements in Asia with Agesilaus, 399-394 b.c. ; at Sparta, 394-387 b.c.

Thus he took the resolution, and with lightness of heart, if in humbleness of soul, set sail. He was under the protection of Zeus the Saviour and of Heracles the Leader ; what then need he fear ? Perhaps in secret he nursed an Achillean hope, ” But my fame shall be imperishable,” as with an attendant soothsayer he started from Ephesus to join his friends at Sardis,

1 The thought suggests itself that he may really have served as a knight under the Thirty. DoubUess there had been many “left centre” democrats so employed, but as a body that class of citizens was not in good odour. No mischief befell them except that some of them had to forfeit their allowances (/cardcrracrts), and when the opportunity arrived the more conspicuous instruments of the Thirty were sent off on foreign service under the Spartan harmost Thibron in 399 ; somewhat, as it would seem, in malum rem. However neutral the part which Xenophon, on this hypothesis, had played, his political career at Athens would have commenced (he may have felt) under difficulties in spite of the amnesty, which ft”om himself we know was, for the matter of that, religiously observed. But this is pure speculation. There is another point. Either now or possibly on his return to Europe in 399 B.C. , he seems to have had an interview (at Megara) with another enemy of the democracy, the Spartan Lysander. So I gather from the expressions put into the mouth of Socrates in the Economist (Oec. iv. 20), which must surely refer to some personal experience of the author. If this interview took place and now, Lysander naturally had fine stories to tell about Cyrus. According to another hypothesis, Thucydides perhaps died in 403 B.C., and Xenophon had for the last year or so been busily employed in editing his great predecessor’s works, and supplementing them by his own Paraleipomena {Hellenica, Bks. I. and II. iii. 10). At the end of that literary labour he was in need of a holiday. If so, a shooting excursion in Pisidia in the company of Proxenus and this fine fellow Cyrus was just the thing for him. His warmth in the matter is shown by the manner in which he consulted the god (see below, p. 146) ; his too late repentance (seeing that the thoughtless step led to exile) by the remark, possibly, in Memorab, I. i. 4. But this again is pure hypothesis.

and at the outset the god vouchsafed him a sign. An eagle sat perched on the wayfarer’s right hand, portending glory not without alloy of suffering, but untainted by any huckstering gain of money. The full import of the omen, as in the case of another later revelation, was only made plain by the events which followed ; yet it served, maybe, to fix his purpose and to stimulate his ardour. Little he recked of evils to come, as the blood coursed healthily through his veins and regally the sungod smiled upon his going. Blitheness indeed and buoyancy in spite of some occasional passing cloud of despondency, are the distinctive characteristics of the Anabasis, that prose epic of historic Greece, into which the author has with much skill interwoven a chapter of his life. Still ta-day, as we read the story, an unaccustomed spirit lifts us above the ground with cheerful thoughts. Here too, on the side of action, Xenophon appears at his best. Here he is most truly Greek, nor does he stand alone ; ”EAAiyvcs act 7rai8cs would be a fitting motto to the work, in compliment to the adventurous warriors who rise above their baser selves in adversity, and claim kinship with the heroes of the Iliad, There are at the same time certain traits of disposition which serve in some degree to distinguish the protagonist The vein of religiousness which pervades the story is of this idiosyncratic sort. This TjOo^ Oeoa-e^es (as the ancient critics would have called it) is strong enough at times to tinge the narrative with an inner parabolic meaning. The romantic march becomes an allegory of a souFs adventure, in which the mighty ones of earth are cast down and the little one is exalted : in which effeminacy, treachery, and arrogance may work mischievously for a season, but in the end are brought to nought; while the faithful God-fearing man who helps himself and patiently endures will win in the end salvation. Xenophon’s own habit was, he tells us, to turn, as Socrates had taught him to do, in matters beyond the ken of man’s wit to decide, for help to heaven. Illustrations of this behaviour on his part are plentiful. His relations indeed to the heavenly powers resemble those of Hermogenes in the Symposium or of Socrates himself^ He is so dear to the gods that they will not leave him without a sign, when a sign is

^ See Symp. iv. 47 foll. ; Mem, IV. iii. 12 foll.

needed. Either in dreams ^ or sacrifices, by birds, or voices, or by something encountered on the path, they graciously make known their will to him. A modern man may smile at the machinery of divination; but, as bearing witness to an inner need of our common humanity, he will welcome the childlike trustfulness and reverence of the pious Athenian captain.

Another trait of this period may be spoken of as the awakening of dormant ambition in the breast of one who was too diffident to snatch at honour, but on whom honour was thrust We can follow the growth of this sentiment from the moment when it became apparent that the raid into Pisidia was a pretext, since Cyrus was flying at lordlier game than certain irrepressible hill tribes.

Perhaps at Issi or at Myriandus Xenophon might have withdrawn, as he was free to do. But hke Proxenus,^ if in a less degree, he felt under an obligation to his host; he had laid his hand to the plough, and it was base to turn back. Curiosity in itself was a further incentive, as the military aspect of the expedition grew in fascination. How far was this boasted Persian empire open to attack ?^ Lastly^ there was doubtless a personal side to the matter. It was but natural to forecast events. Cyrus in his free-handed way had promised crowns and satrapies to his Greek officers.* He, Xenophon, though unofficially attached, would certainly not be forgotten. He would return home with enlarged experience, and the wherewithal to benefit a friend. The death of Cyrus dispelled these fancies. But others of a more permanent character took their place. Between the battle of Sept. 3 and the passage

^ One of these signs has already been mentioned, nor need I forestall the reader’s pleasure in picking them out for himself. They are of real psychological interest. In particular, the dreams — that on the night of the seizure of the generals, or that other (a Uttpos 5ta)Sari/c6s) at the passage of the Centrites — help us to follow the workings of his mind. They remind one of St. Paul’s vision of the man of Macedonia (Alexander the Great ?), dreamt in the vicinity of •’ sacred Ilion,” and were in a spiritual sense “veridical.” See for this, and for other traits of character — e.^. his strategical skill ; his combined tact and eloquence ; his philanthropy exhibited towards barbarians no less than the Cyreians ; the awakening of his personal ambition ; his colonisation schemes ; his respect for law and authority, his ficiove^ia — Index ” Xenophon.”

3 See pp. 127, 147. * See p. 97. * See p. 102.

of the Tigris (Oct 5), a month of suspense intervened. The brains of the young scholar or philosopher were working. the while. He was duly taking note of the surroundings.^ The germ of a colonisation scheme,* which was never realised indeed but never laid aside, belongs to this interval So, doubtless, does the germ of that lordlier undertaking, which in the fulness of time was amply realised — ^the conquest and absorption by Hellas of the Persian empire.*

The murder of the generals on the fatal 2 2d of October

transformed the theorist into the man of action. In the

visions of that night a new spirit bred of sharp necessity and

. true courage entered him. A voice summoned him to the

J leadership in a forlorn hope. In obeying the call he found

himself not in name only, but after a brief apprenticeship, in

^ very deed, what he had aspired to be, a ruler of men. The

I story of his generalship is told with ample detail in the four

last books of the Anabasis^ and need not be repeated here.

I I confine myself to general observations.*

^ We shall find traces of this in his latest works. See Cyrop, passim.

His notes are those of an intelligent traveller, observant of men and

manners and scenery, with a taste for sport. But he has further the keen

£ critical eye of the war correspondent or military attach^. See pp. 97, 126,

r etc. In the Cyropaedia we * traverse the same ground and fight the old

y battles over again.

  • For the gradual working out of this project, see p. 158 note i, and p. 258 foll. He cherished it all his life as we suspect. At Calpe it seemed on the point of realisation, but at a sudden turn of affairs (the advent of a Spartan admiral) the dream melted, into thin air. The rock fortress which was to have become an independent little state with great powers of expansion and the happiest future before it, had to be deserted. Its abandonment was

7 evidently a blow to Xenophon’s ambition, but it is not his habit to repine.

’ Self-eflEacement of a sort is easy to him.

I ’ We discover both, in the reflection how easy it would be to plant them-

selves as a military colony in the heart of Babylonia, p. 157. In its immediate conception strategical, this project presented a philanthropic side. Such a colony, wherever planted, would serve to draw off a portion of the surplus population from his native city and to diminish pauperism (see Vect. i. i). To be the [oecist or) founder of such a settlement would have satisfied the personal ambition of Xenophon. But there was no chance of gratifying it at

•» present in the basin of the Tigris.

  • The reader who wishes rapidly to piece together the leading personal ’ details can do so by turning to the Index and reading what is there given under

the name of ” Xenophon.” The authenticity of the story is another matter. There is, I believe, no just ground for doubting it. The part which Xenophon assigns himself is somewhat idealised ; but these were the facts. This indeed

The path of leadership is glorious but beset with peril. According to Xenophon’s mature reflection, it can only be trodden with absolute success by the real prince;^ and the qualities requisite are not to be found in ordinary mortals. That he was able himself to play the part with credit for a season must be ascribed at qnce to his native Attic ability and to his Socratic training. To Athens he owed that happy combination of eloquence and confidence with soldier -like resource and bravery,^ which his countrymen regarded as the natural outcome of their democratic institutions. To Socrates may be traced those ruling qualities of sympathy and humanheartedness, and that readiness to take the lion’s share of fatigue and danger, which won him the obedience and affection of the soldiers. This volunteer was no pretentious charlatan, else they would soon have exploded him. Nor was he a mere rule-of-thumb tactician and drill-sergeant, or it would have fared but ill with him and them. He had, it was soon seen, a real gift of inventiveness and a sound economic sense.* An instinct told him how best to adapt the means at his disposal to a given end ; and that too in the face of ancient methods.

is the charm, or one charm, of the Anabasis, It contains, as I have elsewhere suggested, not only a graphic account of a notable episode of Greek history, but it constitutes a chapter of autobiography m which the personal element subserves to the general dramatic interest of the narrative. Without being unfaithful to Clio, the muse of history, the author uses his tablet and stylus in the service of her sister Calliope. And of his own prose epic he is the central figure. So he behaved. Such was the real meaning, the true interpretation, of his intent and conduct From another point of view, the interest of the Anabasis centres in its military problems. It might have served, like the Commentaires of Blaise de Montluc, as a * ’ soldier’s breviary ” or vade mecum. It was not the Anabasis ^ however, but the Cyropaedia, a work based to a great extent on the Anabasis, which Africanus carried about with him. See Cic. Tusc. II. xxvi. 62. ” Semper Africanus Socraticiun Xenophontem in manibus habebat, cujus imprimis laudabat illud (Cyr. I. vi. 25), quod diceret, eosdem labores non esse aeque graves imperatori et militi, quod ipse honos laborem leviorem faceret imperatorium.” Cf. Ep, ad, Q. Fratr, /., I. viii. 23. *’ Quos quidem libros non sine causa noster ille Africanus de manibus ponere non solebat : nullum est enim praetermissum in his officium diligentis et moderati imperii.”

^ “The Archie Man.” See Cyrop, I. i. 9x16. si. passim ; Hipparch.; also Mem. IV. ii. II.

2 The words are Grote’s, H, G, ix, p. 117, ist ed. See also Curtius, H. G. (Eng. tr.), iv. 130.

  • tt’^rXfl^iKbi. olKOvofJHK6s, See Mem. III. i. 6; IV. ii. 11.

Whatever his prior military experience may have been, he had studied in no narrow-minded spirit He was all the more apt to learn the handling of troops in the school of experience. If, for instance, the ground which they were forced to traverse were not suitable to the evolutions in vogue, it seemed a matter of sound sense, no less than of generalship, to suit their tactics to their novel circumstances. Opportunities for such modifications of method in march and battle daily presented themselves. The experience so gained was of permanent value. If, therefore, it is to the credit of the Ten Thousand collectively that they were able to face bhthely a long series of ever-shifting difficulties, it is equally to the honour of Xenophon and his colleagues that the strain was not greater. To him and them attaches the glory of the pioneer. They are

^ reformers in the art of warfare. How far Xenophon can be

I fairly regarded as the monopolist of these reforms is not an easy question. It is he, however, who has explained them to

, us, and they savour of his inventiveness.^

But apart from these traits of originality, self-devotion, and

’ alertness — characteristic in themselves of the archie man, there is no doubt that Xenophon possessed what he himself would have regarded as the sine qua non of success in leadership. ^ This special qualification of the Hellenic happy warrior he had in his pious disposition. His, as I have already said, was a quite child-like faith and a trust in divine providence. This attitude of mind did not render him superstitious or inactive.

^ They carry the hall-mark, as one may say, of his particular genius, bearing a strong family likeness to the literary innovations which his written works exemplify. As to the tactical reforms in question, they were discussed at the council of war by all the generals, etc. , and the whole board must have the credit of their adoption. But it is almost certain that the prime mover was not unfrequently the Athenian. This seems to have been the opinion of the ancients, though there is no direct contemporary evidence in proof. It is also the opinion of important modern authorities. What seems quite certain is, that ihe modifications in the handling of heavy and light infantry and cavalry, and the combined evolutions of these troops, which were presently adopted in Greek warfare, e.g. in some of Agesilaus’s battles (in Asia and at Coronea), were primarily due to the experiences of the Ten Thousand. See Riistow and Kochly, Gesch. d, Griech, Kriegswesens, p. 158 (note 19), and the references to Xenophon and other authorities there given, Anab. V. iv. 22, p. 222 ; Ages, ii. 9-14; Hell. IV. iii. 15; Plut. Ages, 18; Diod. xiv. 84; Polyaen. ii. 1,4; 0, 19 ; Frontin, ii. 6, 222. ^ See Cyrop, I. vi, 46,

xcn SKETCH OF THE

It did not leave him open to the chicaneries of every lying soothsayer.^ On the contrary it gave him confidence in the practical affairs of life and a sense of security in dark places.^ It enabled him also to acquiesce in the many personal disappointments which at this period awaited him. It saved him fi:om the torture to which certain sympathetic natures are liahle, the consciousness of talents wasted in fond subservience to the will of others. But the disappointments were very real. It is a proof indeed of his literary skill that he can present them so vividly without wearying his readers by the enumeration of them.

These were, to put it briefly, the offences which must needs come to a man like Xenophon so exceptionally circumstanced. Some may be traceable to a certain weakness in his nature, /since, as above suggested, he was (to use an epithet of his own) /to some extent dipsychic and the cherisher of incompatible Idesires.^ The larger portion of them, however, were the outcome of what was most honourable to him, his insatiable striving after honour.* The rest spring out of the inevitable misunderstandings of the situatioa It must be, in so motley

^ See Cyrop, I. vi. 2, and see p. 233 for a practical illustration.

’ So at any rate he seems to feel ; and one may well believe. It did not of course instruct him ethically. It did not precisely quicken his social or his political conscience. How should it ? By which I am far from implying that these stood in any special need of quickening. His feelings towards slaves and “barbarians” are markedly philanthropic. His anti-Theban bias is the common narrow-mindedness of active political partisanship. It, like the rest of his political shortcoming, is compatible with an exalted pan-HeUenic patriotism, resembling that of Lysias and Isocrates.

’ Incompatible desires. — E.g. he wishes to return home,- but he will not abandon the army — or go against the wUl of the God — or he does not find it easy to break with the Spartan governors. His proper respect for vested authority looks at times like subservience ; or is his vacillation owing to a growing sense of insecurity at home ? (See below. )

^iXoTifda : his chief ambition is to rule and to obey. toO Apx^i-y re koX &pX€(r0ai : to do or share in some famous deed. The successful conduct of the advance — and still more so, of the retreat — ought surely to redound to their credit and his. That is his hope. To found a colony is a scheme which appeals to his sense of economy. It is a practical thing to do. It leads to honour. To possess a sea -board fortress is a more simply self- regarding scheme. By the end of the year 400 B.c. he has come to regard himself as a possible rolling stone. He is in the category of the mercenary captains, or may be. This idea seems to have occupied his mind only during the last winter, when his hopes of fame were beginning to dwindle and his apprehension of certain Spartans and of Pharnabazus had grown large.

  • See Cyrop. passim ; Hiero, viL 3.

a host and with so many rival captains, some generous and others the reverse, in eager competition, that ofifences against an Athenian private gentleman without followers to back him should come ; so soon at least as the immediate difficulties were past and there was time to attend to private advantages. This did not make them the less bitter. With Xenophon at least we shall agree that the elemental forces of nature were not so hard to battle with as those various moral evils which beset the army from Trapezus onwards. As to himself personally we can well understand that the tooth of an Armenian or Scythian winter did not bite like a fellow-man’s ingratitude. But underlying the last books of the Anabasis is the sense of something more than disappointment I think we must call it a sense of disillusionment^ It is not spoken of tediously with many words ; but here and there a phrase well suited to its context, like the echo of a sigh, pathetically reveals it ” Somewhere,” he says, as he parts with the Thracian princeling Seuthes,to whom he has restored a kingdom and without reward, “somewhere I may rise^honour; and that shall redound to your gain also.”^ Let us consider this matter. I have already spoken of the colonisation scheme. The abandonment of it was on each occasion doubtless a blow to his hopes.^ ” For myself I have done with that dream, ’ betrays the feeling of a sacrifice. But to turn the troops to so good an account — to become famous as the oecist of a new and thriving settlement — was not his sole personal ambition, nor its abandonment his only act of self-sacrifice. It was only part and parcel of the more general ambition which he cherished. He cared much for the good name and fame of his fellow-soldiers. For himself, he hoped that some echo of his success as a commander might be borne on the wings of fame to Hellas : that, to use his own phrase, he might one day reach his native city^ and find his name writ large.® At a certain date in the month of

^ This is intelligible enough when we bear in mind that the work itself, or, at any rate, a portion of it, could not have been finally composed tmtil long alter the years (401-399 B.C.) in which the incidents took place.

  • See page 314. • Page 234.

^ Page 240. ” The praises we expect to win from the mouths of men.’ ^ Page 248.

• The desire to return home is first expressed in the speech at Cotyora,

May (400 B.C.), whilst the army lay at Harmene, the port of Sinope,^ and the proximity to their goal brought self-regarding feelings to the surface, it looked for one moment as if Xenophon were about to reap the first-fruits of a well-earned reputation. After a public meeting of the soldiers, the sole generalship was formally offered to him. But this honour, gratifying to his personal vanity, had, in obedience to the will of heaven, to be foregone. Firmly, and without repining, he put it aside. Yet he makes no secret of a certain perturbation. However plain the duty — however salutary the consequences — of self-effacement in the future, for the moment his hopes were disappointed. There were other disappointments of a similar sort in- store for him — before Byzantium — at Selybria, and again during his service under Seuthes. On every occasion the higher — at least the more reasonable — nature of the man wins an easy battle over some subordinate inclinatioa Zeus is ever his saviour ; Heracles is his guide.

It must, however, be admitted that these triumphs are somewhat at the expense of self-assertiveness. I do not mean that Xenophon ever ceased to be a man of action. If he sometimes let” I dare not ” wait upon ” I will,” the hero within hhn reasserted itself It was never swallowed up by the philosopher. But at times that nearly happened. What between his sense of fairness on the one hand, and his infinite regard for law on the other, his will was kept in abeyance. This man has none of the self-aggrandising dash of Alcibiades. For vested authority he has an infinite respect. It is astonishing how readily he accepts the hegemony of Sparta at this period, as if it belonged to the eternal order of the universe. It is thus that, externally at any rate (though with his inner being it is quite otherwise), his life becomes as it were the plaything and sport of fortune. Thus we find this great Athenian captain playing the ignoble part of tennis-ball to rival Spartan harmosts. When he has a chance to return home his desire to keep the army together, in compliance with the schemes of

June 400, in which he abandons the colonisation scheme (p. 234). It is repeated at Heraclea in July ; but the design is vetoed by Heracles (the Leader) (P* 253). Again, in August, at Chrysopolis ; and at Byzantium, August to October (pp. 274, 275-279). Again, in February of ttfe next year, 399 B.C., on leaving Seuthes (p. 314). ^ Page 2^9.

Anaxibius, leads him to prolong his stay. The counter views of Aristarchus drive him to undertake the Thracian campaign with Seuthes ; and the end of it all is that the escape from one Spartan, Aristarchus, throws him into the arms of another, Thibron.

During these last months (the winter campaign in Thrace) Xenophon has an uneasy suspicion that one day he may need a private fortress (like Alcibiades before him) as a harbour of refuge from political storms.^ But Bisanthe, Ganos and Neon Teichos, like the city that might have been of Calpe, prove but cloud-castles. Owing to the weakness of Seuthes the Thracian prince, and the machinations of a false Hellene (Heracleides), the Asiatic campaign is less remunerative to Xenophon than the Cyreian expedition. Chiefly through his disinterestedness he finds himself all but beggared, when, for the last time postponing his departure homewards, he consents to hand over the Cyreians in person to their new paymaster Thibron in Asia. The old family soothsayer Eucleides^ is clever in his diagnosis. This man is an obstacle to himself. Zeus Meilichios is a further obstacle. As far as the god is concerned there is a speedy cure ; but I need not repeat the story already referred to. We leave Xenophon at the end of the Anabasis enriched as he little expected to be. He is not only in the lap of luxury, but he is in the midst of friends. He is at home with the family of Gongylus the Eretrian, his sons and their mother Hellas. He is popular with the army, men and officers. His old friends the Cyreians vie with his new Laconian friends in honouring him. Zeus Meilichios is well appeased. But do we leave him freed from the self-hindrance of his own compliant nature ? I think not. On the contrary, this same selfhindrance would seem to have been the very principle of his spiritual development. A worse thing than the lack of means was about to happen to him — the loss of his country. The causes of that catastrophe are still a matter of speculation. If it were possible to divine them, they would be found, I think, to exemplify the diagnosis of Eucleides, ” You are an obstacle to yourself.” But of this matter enough.

^ See p. 286, in case of difficulty with Lacedaemon in the first instance ; also pp. 298, 307, 313. 8 Page 315.

In the spring of 399 B.a Xenophon, if not himself altogether a different person, is differently conditioned from the youth who in this same month of March just two years ago set out from Athens to join Proxenus and Cjrus. Both these friends and many others were dead. Socrates was at the point of death.^ In what direction should he turn now, this man with his Achillean aspirations and his Odyssean cautiousness; his almost Socratic independence in things of the soul, his sophistic scrupulosity, or should it be said, his Attic dyxi’Voia in practical affairs? In a material sense he was more free to move, but politically he was more isolated. If he had now at last something in his pocket wherewith to benefit a friend, was he likely to find his name written large in the hearts of his own countrymen? would he even be welcomed as a virtuous citizen at home? There the tide of conservative reaction was setting in apace. The most deserving section of the party — the saviours of the Democracy — were naturally well-disposed to Thebes; the citizens in general resented the leadership of Sparta. Was the Democracy for ever to play a secondary part ? Was not empire the birthright of Athenians ? On the whole, and however great his natural inclination to return home,^ this was scarcely an opportune moment for a citizen of his antecedents to think of establishing himself at Athens. It is Xenophon himself who bears witness to the generous and reasonable behaviour of the restored Democracy.* It is he who has

^ Socrates drank the hemlcx^k in May. It is not probable that Xenophon ever saw him again. When and where he heard the account of his trial and condemnation, we cannot tell. Perhaps with other considerations it combined to determine his movements now.

2 See the last two books of the Anabasis, passim (pp. 234, 253, 274, 275, 279, 314). Grote thinks that he did return for a short while, during which time he brought out his Paraleipomena and then returned to Asia, rejoining the remnant of the Cyreians undo- the Spartan harmost Thibron or his successor Dercylidas. Others have thought that he did not return at all, or that he got no farther on the homeward journey than Megara, where he would have heard from the Socratics what fate had befallen their friend. There is something plausible in this last view of his movements. He probably had his papers to put in order ; and possibly a book to publish. If so, was it now that he interviewed Lysander ? See above.

^ See p. 75 of this volume. As Grote points out, the verse of Aeschylus Tpax«5$ 7€ fJL^Toi drj/Jios iK^vyCjv kukA especially did not apply to the restored Democracy. See If, G, viii. p. 415 (2d ed.)

recorded a significant incident, which serves to illustrate the spirit of the times. Among the troops of Thibron, he tells us, was a contingent of cavalry sent out by Athens, as her quota, in obedience to the ruling power. It consisted of those knights who had been of special service to the Thirty. In thus obeying the mandate of Sparta the home authorities were probably stirred by two desires. They wished, on the one hand, to deal justly by people of opposite politics, and, on the other, to be rid of political firebrands. In the language of the historian, they believed it would be a gain to the Democracy for these people to see some foreign service, and if it cost them their lives it was no great loss.^ The feeling of the authorities towards these knights was a straw to show which way the wind blew, and if Xenophon had contemplated returning home in hopes to find his name writ large, perhaps the talk of these men and the story of Socrates* fate served to disenchant him. The latter tragic incident, whenever and wherever the news reached him, must have come as a great shock to him. He does not talk about it Neither in the Memorabilia nor elsewhere does he speak angrily of the accusers, still less so of the Athenian public,^ least of all does he allow any note of personal resentment to obtrude upon the solemn sadness of an irretrievable loss.

Whether he returned to Europe or not during the spring or summer of this year, it seems certain that he was back in Asia before its close. The internal evidence derived from certain books of the Hellenica (III. and IV.) ^ appears conclusive on that point. In some way, officially or non-

^ ol 5’ ^ir€fi\l/av tCjv ivl tQv rptdKoyra lirireva&ffTwv vofd^ovra Kipdos rf S^^fjup, el dirodrjfMHep /col ivaTr&XoiyTo, What actually became of them we do not kiiow.

^ As he reflected on this matter later in life he was able to form a perfectly considerate judgment. It was in a fit of jealousy (pardonable in frail humanity) that the Athenian public had acted. Ddmos, as a 6on ptre de famille^ had turned against the philosophic tutor who had stolen the affections of his darling son. This is the apologue of the allusive passage in the Cyropaedia (III. i. 38-40). The bons pires de famille are represented by the Armenian. His son Tigranes is the youth of Athens, whom the philosopher had “corrupted.” Cyrus is the outer world interested to discover the real explanation of so sad 9. story.

« As the minuteness of detail implying the personal knowledge of an eyewitness seemis to show.

officially, he was connected with the Spartan harmosts in Asia off and on for five years (399-394 b.c) — if not with Thibron himself, to whom he had surrendered the six thousand Cyreians, at any rate with Dercylidas first, ^ and later with Agesilaus. With this latter,^ in the year 394 B.C., he certainly did return to Europe, and was present consequently, whether he fought or not, at the battle of Coronea.

This was a momentous period in Xenophon’s life. Within its scope fall to be considered not only his marriage and the birth of his sons, but his exile and that which in connexion with his exile closely affected his whole after-life — a. new friendship with the Spartan king Agesilaus.

To speak of these in some order. The date of his marriage can be approximately fixed * as falling in the year 399 B.C. or soon after. Who his wife was, we do not know. One may suspect that he found her in the Aeolid, perhaps in the pleasant home of Hellas, the wife of Gongylus, or of some other of his Pergamene friends ; but this is mere gUesswork. She may have been a foreigner, or she may have been an Athenian, a native of the Aeolid, or one of those women who had shared in the campaign. There is no saying. That she became the mother of two noble sons named Gryllus and Diodorus, we know; and that her own name was Philesia. Possibly the boys were twins, as their Spartan sobriquet TAe Dioscuri suggests. They were popularly named “the great twin brethren,” and became famous. As to Philesia herself, their mother, she is, we suspect, the prototype of some one or other of those delightful women worthy of Zeuxis and Euripides, whom Xenophon has depicted.* Perhaps it was of her

1 See I/el/. III. i. ao ; ii. 25.

» See Anad. V. iii. 7 (p. 218 below) ; ffeli, IV. iii. 15 ; Hut. Ages. 18.

’ I speak here of his marriage with Philesia, the mother of his two sons Gryllus and Diodorus. It is possible that she was his second wife. And if we could accept it as authentic, the pretty story repeated by Cicero {de Invent. i. 31) on the authority of Aeschines, the Socratic (cf. Quintil. V. ii. 27), of a dialogue between Aspasia, Xenophon, and Xenophon’s wife, would imply that he had been married before he left Athens in 401 B.C. ; indeed so many years before that we should be driven to 440 B.c. (circa) as the date of his birth. But the conversation is doubtless imaginary. .So, too, is the Soteira of one of the epistles, commonly held to be spurious. Stob. FhriL 3, 29.

  • And Heywood, the Elizabethan, reproduced. See below, p. cxxviii.

he thought when he drew the portrait of the wife of Tigranes, ” who went soldiering with her own man,” in the Cyropaedia. As might be expected, we get no hint from Xenophon himself in these matters; nor does he once have occasion to name his wife. Such silence is only natural and common. It is, of course, quite compatible widi the existence of those happy relations which, from the pen of Xenophon himself, best of all Greek writers, we know to have subsisted between husband and wife in ancient Greece.^

I^ as seems probable, Xenophon and Philesia were married in 399 B.a, we may perhaps be warranted in assuming that their two sons were bom to them within the next two years — ^possibly both in 398 B.C. or 397 rc; or, if not twins, within a year of each other, the elder in 398-397 B.C and the younger in 397-396 b.c ; so that at the date when their father left Asia with Agesilaus on the perilous expedition of 394 B.C, the two children would still be at their mother’s apron-string. Perhaps for a couple of years the family life was so far broken up that the mother and children remained at home in Asia, whilst the father followed the fortune of his friend the king of Sparta in Europe. But in 392 b.c. it recommenced, and as fortune willed it, was happily continued for many years ; first in Sparta itself and afterwards at SciUus.^

In this summary application of the almanac to the private Hfe of our author, we may seem to have too long neglected the stormier question of his public bearing and his banishment. To this we come.

If we do not know the precise date of Xenaphon’s marriage, still less do we know the date of his banishment ; and if we are ignorant as to the date, still more are we ignorant as

^ See, in particular, the relations of Ischomachus and his wife in the Economist; the Cyropaedia^ passim; and for Xenophon’ s views as to rejcvoleoda. and the education of childreUj see in addition to the above-named works Lac. Pol, I ; Mem, I. iv. 7.

^ The evidence for the date of Xenophon’ s marriage and the birth of his sons is as follows : — (i) We know on the best authority (from Anctb, VII. vi. 34, p. 305) that he was not married, or at any rate had no children, in February 399 B.C. (2) We further know, on the authority of Plutarch in his life of Agesilaus, that, at some interval between 394 and 381 B.C. (see Hell, IV. iv. 19), when Xenophon was with Agesilaus in Sparta, his sons were (not only bom, i>ut) of an age to be initiated into the public training acpording to the

to the cause and circumstances of that ooconence. The ancients themselves^ attributed it in some way or other to

institution of Lycuigus : wfaidi 071^79 <^ Spartan lads oommenoed aft the age oi seven, Plutarch’s words are: “He (Agesilaiis) fcqit with him Xenophon the ^^ulosopher, and made much of him, and proposed to him to said far his children and educate them at Sparta, where they would be tan^it the best of an learning; bow to ob^ and how to command” (Qougfa, 4. 24). This Xenophon appeazs to have done. It win folfil the conditions best if we suppose that Xenophon on leaving Asia in 394 Re had left his wife and children there (at Ephesus or elsewhere). Or, to state the matter chronologically : Supposing that his marriage took .place in 399 BwC, and that the diildren were bom both in 398-397 blc: (or at an interval of a year) ; in 392 B.C. they (or the elder of them) would be about six years of age, and almost ripe for the Spartan pubUc schooling, which commenced at the age of seven. See Phtt Ages. xx. ScFo0(i)rra Zk ri^ awpbif ^”^ V^ iavrw [‘Ayi^/Xoof] ffTOvSa^Sfiewot iidXeve roirs raidas hf AoKedal/umi rp^tev fji€TaT€fi^dfi€ifoi^, Cn fia0if(ro/Uwous tQw itadtf^viTiaw rb icdXAurror, /^eo^cu Kol Apxeuf, See Roquette, Xen. Vil. I. § 5, p. 25.

^ It win be best to cite the ancient authorities : —

Besides two passages in Xenophon himself {Anah. V. iii. 7, and VII. 57), which must be considered in reference at least to the date (see pp. 218, 314), we have the statements of three ancient authorities, none of which are very close to the times of Xenophon. The earliest is Dio Chiysostom (the £eunous rhetorician of the Flavian era, 100 A.D.), who tells us that ’* Xenophon was exiled owing to his expedition with Cyrus,” ^cyo^ftay i<pvy€ 5id tV fjuerk KOpov (rpaTelav (viii. p. 130 m), but how, why, or when, he does not explain. The next is Pausanias, the archaeologist, etc. (160 A.D.), who adds a suggestion. “Xenophon was banished by the Athenians as having shared in the expedition against the king, their weU-wisher, with Cyrus, who was the bitterest foe of the Democracy,” iSidjx^V ^ Sevo^wv inrb AdTp^ad(tnf uk irrl pafftKia (nfUffOf e0vow 6vT(t ffTpareias fieraaxi^ Ki^/xp iroXe^ubn-dry tov ^fJLOv (v. 6, s). There seems to be some hope of a discovery here, but it is after all delusive, since, as Grote points out, Artaxerxes only became ei^om to Athens in 396 B.C., and Xenophon’s friendship with Cyrus was an old story then. The last authority is Diogenes Laertius. He has two references to the matter. The first is contained in one of the two epigrams which he wrote in honoiu” of Xenophon (see above, p. xliv. , and below, p. 146), in which occur the words K4kpot6s ere iroXtrat €&Y€iv Kariyvwv tov </)[\ov x^P”^ K6pov, “Thee Cecrops’ citizens condemned to exile for thy dear Cyrus’s sake’ (Diogenes Laertius, Life of Xen. § 14). The other occurs a little earlier (in § 7), where he tells us that ’ ’ after the ’ Anabasis ’ and the occurrences in Pontus (in the ’ Catabasis ’), and the breaches of faith on the part of Seuthes, the king of the Odrysians, Xenophon came to Asia to Agesilaus, the king of Lacedaemon, and presented him with Cyrus’s soldiers for pay (?.^. as a mercenary force).” [This is clearly a blunder, since he came to Thibron in 399 B.C., to whom he handed over the Cyreians, and to Dercylidas later on in the year, and to Agesilaus only in 396 B.C. ] “It was at this time ” [what time? 399 b.c. or 396 B.c.?] he adds, ’ ’ that he was condemned to exile by the Athenians on the ground of Laconism : furb, di rV ovdpouriv koX rd; iv r{; 1I6vt<p avfKpopiis Kal rds irapaaTrovS^eis rAf Xtiidov rod ‘OdpwrQv pcurCKiw ^k€p eU ^Aalav npbs ‘AyrjaCXaov rbv AaKtiaifMtviwi’ pa<riKia,t fUffBoO roi/s Kdpov ffrpaTLunai aiT$ trapaax^^t

his friendship with Cjrrus, or (scarcely less vaguely) to his

^iXos re ^ els inrepPoK’fyf, trap *6y Koxphv hrl AaxdypurfUfi ^iryV ^’ ^AdrivcUdnf KaTeyvt&adri. Diogenes is an unsatisfactory authority, and generally contrives to confuse matters through carelessness. But on the whole we must admit that his testimony, like that of the other two authorities, is positively in favour of an earlier date than 394 B. c. , and negatively of a less pronounced form of Laconism than would have been Xenophon’s presence with the enemy of the allies and Athens at Coronea. On this intricate question the modem authorities are nearly equally divided. Thus Grote is quite clear that the sentence of banishment was not passed until after the battle of Coronea, which took place in August 394 B.C. ; and he states clearly the grounds of his opinion in H, G, voL ix. 242 note i, which he reiterates as an historical fact in Plato, III. zxxix. p. 566. Curtius, on the other hand (Eng. tr., vol. v. p. 149, bk. vii, ch. ii.), takes an opposite view. “Thus Xenophon when probably not more than thirty years of age entered the service of Cyrus, and was unexpectedly called upon to perform duties of high importance, in which he exhibited so much efficiency that his fame even radiated itself upon Athens. And yet by what he did he incurred the loss of his native city ; for probably about the time when proceedings against all anti-constitutional tendencies were resumed at Athens (vol. iv. p. 142), and when Socrates was sentenced, Xenophon was by a popular decree deprived of his civic rights as a partisan of Cyrus ; possibly a diplomatic consideration for the wishes of the Persian king contributed to bring about this decision,” etc. With this in the main I agree. I will only add a note on the two passages in the Anabasis above referred to. The first occurs on p. 218 and note 4, The words run thus : ^vw^Qjv Hre dir^i cifp *AyriffiKd(fi iK ttjs ‘Aclas rV ^^s ‘BouaToi>s Mv, KaraXeLirei {rb t^s Afyr4fudoi ftjipos) vaph M€7a/3i5fw … koX ^ir^tfraXev, ^ fiiv a^bs trw^J, ^avrj) dfroSovvai ^ di Ti vddij, difa$€iv(u iroajadfiepov r^ ‘Aprifudi 6 tl (^oito xa/M6r<r^(u r^ ^e^^) ‘Evel 5 i^evyev d ^cyo(ay, KaToiKowTos liSr) iv DjctXXoOi^t, d^tfcmrou TAeyd^v^os. … It has been asked by those who rely on this passage to prove that Xenophon was banished after 394 B.C., ” Why should he mention his banishment at all in this context, if it had occurred five years or so before he set off with Agesilaus to Europe?” To those who are not satisfied with Thirlwall’s explanation (see H. G. iv. ch. xxxiv. p. 357, and in reference to Anab, V. iii. 7, Xenophxm, Niebuhr, and Delbrueck, Philol. Mus, vol. i. p. 516), I would suggest that the expression is natural enough, if at the date of publication of the Anabasis Uie sentence had been rescinded. It is highly probable that this was the case. Xenophon was, I think, forced to leave Scillus, and settled in Corinth soon after the battle of Leuctra, 371 B.C. The sentence of banishment was rescinded not later, I think, than 369 B.C., possibly earlier; and the Anabasis published almost simultaneously. But this will need further discussion in a later volume. In any case I do not consider the inference to be drawn from Anab, V. iii. 7 conclusively in favour of 394 B.C. And the suggestion, if in that direction, may be met by the suggestion of Anab, VII. vii. 57 : Scvo^wy bk oif vpocjuii, dXXd ap€pbs ^ oUabe Trapa^Keva^bfievos’ oi> ydp irw yj/rj^os aifrt} iirrjKTO ^Ad-fiv^aL irepl ipvyijSi which surely implies that the incident of his banishment did presently prevent him from carrying out his intention to return home. The only escape from that conclusion is to suppose that the words 0^ ydp irw K.r.X. are an editor’s note — wrongly inserted in the text — a footnote, as it

«

Laconism?’ But in what particular way this Laconism was shown, or how and why either Laconism or friendship with Cyrus should have brought upon him a sentence of exile, is at the present time altogether a matter of conjecture. Under the circumstances it will be fairer at once to Xenophon and to my readers, if I state here my own conviction that the sentence of exile was passed soon after the events recorded on the last page of the Anabasis (p. 318 of this volume), and that the gravamen of the indictment lay, as the ancients put it, at once in his former friendship with Cyrus and his present (or late) inclination towards Sparta, the ancient enemy of the Democracy. By ” soon after,” I mean within a year or two years (or three at the most). It seems to me not improbable that Pharnabazus himself, or some one of the great king’s personal agents,^

were, cautioning the reader, who thinks of Xenophon as a banished man, not to antedate the commencement of his exile. But that in itself is surely far-fetched. According to Grote he not only was free in 399 b.c. to return to Athens, but for a short while did so. But if so, why in recounting the incidents of 399 b.c. should he go out of his way to speak of a matter which could only affect his movements in 394 B. c. ?

^ A.aK(i)viffiuL6s = a leaning to Sparta, a philo-Laconian propensity or behaviour, not necessarily even in the sphere of practical politics treasonable ; though often enough so actually or so regarded. Cf. ol ^oidyn&^ovTcs, oi dpyoKl^ovres, to express a party in the state favouring a particular policy. To understand Laconism, as I have elsewhere said, we ought to go to a somewhat analogous period — the Italy of the Republics, when Venice with her relative stability and oligarchical government = Sparta ; Florence with her intellectual turmoil and political self-consciousness = Athens. The comparison might be worked out in detail. Fide Symonds, Age of the Despots, ch. iii. passim, and ch. iv. p. 236 ; also Freeman, Historical Essays, 2d series,

p. 32.

2 For the troKvirpay/JUHri^rj of these big men and the litUe men their agents, see Thucydides, and Xenophon, Hell, passim. See too the Anabasis for specimens of the petty scheming busybody and emissary such as Dexippus, Neon perhaps, Medosades, Heraclqides. For the diplomacy of bigger men see the relations of Pharnabazus and Anaxibius, and again of that satrap and Aristarchus. As to the personal catastrophe, the tale told to Xenophon by Seuthes (p. 307) at a certain date, that Thibron meant to put him to death, though falsified by events, shows the sort of hazard which a man of some mark and scanty means might be supposed to run. Still more to the point is the actual risk either of losing his life or being delivered up to Pharnabazus (who had a horror of Cyreians), which befell him earlier, before Perinthus, at the hands of an evilly-disposed Spartan harmost (p. 282). One has only to imagine some Athenian or other of the Dexippus type worked upon by an emissary of Pharnabazus (as the Rhodian Timocrates was employed by the satrap Tithraustes in a grander affair, Hell. III. v. i), or of his own motion working

Greek or foreign (working upon the ecclesia by dint of some Athenian intermediary), may have had a hand in it. There were many such political go-betweens, big or small, who already during the Cyreian expedition, and whilst Athens was still in political vassalage to Sparta, would be on the look-out to undermine the influence of the dominant Hellenic power. Is this probable ? Apart from the relatively small matter of a single man’s private fortunes, it can, I think, be shown to be so.

Even during the earliest period of her supremacy, between 403 B.C. and the Cyreian expedition, when Spartan influence was predominant in Greece and Asia, signs that the tide would soon turn were already visible. The Corinthians and Thebans, who would have been glad in 405 b.c. to see Athens blotted out, were now beginning to be jealous of Sparta rather than of Athens in her present defenceless condition. The high-handed measures of the dominant power shown in her treatment of the Asiatic states, where the Lysandrian Decarchies were a worse scourge than the imperial system of the Democracy had ever been, caused disaffection in Asia and apprehension in Hellas proper. This was not all. The war with Elis, which was simply coercive, was so unpopular with the free states, that though Athens could not but send a contingent, Corinth and Thebes refused to do so when summoned in 400 B.C Thereupon her tactics in Asia were changed, but not skilfully. If the Decarchies were withdrawn, the states were left to the mercy of the new Persian governor Tissaphernes, who showed himself a very different master from Cyrus. The states appealed to Sparta as the wpoo-TaTT/s of Hellas, and her tactics were further changed. A war with the Persian satraps was undertaken. The idea of a national conquest of Persia, a pan-Hellenic march in which Sparta was to represent Hellas, began to fascinate the government. The first step was to send out in 400-399 B.C. a body of troops under Thibron to assist the Ionian cities.^ It consisted of one thousand Spartan neoda-

for Pharnabazus or the king, or in the interests of a political party at Athens, or conceivably in a self-seeking spirit, and for private purposes ; and the psephism of Eubulus, or whoever it was, is not unintelligible. See Note A above. ^ HelL III. L

modes, four thousand Peloponnesians, and the three hundred Athenian knights above spoken of. The Corinthians and Thebans were again recalcitrant They would have nothing to do with the pan-Hellenic march. When the new Agamemnon Agesilaus in 397 kc proposed to ofifer sacrifice in Aulis, the latter laughed him to scorn, and treated the king of men and his sacrifices with prosaic effrontery. Certainly, as Pausanias tells us, they were but little affected by appeals to their gratitude.^ Their grievances were too deeply seated The Corinthians and Athenians more politely — but no less practically — for one plausible reason or another begged to be excused. Nothing has been said of Argos. There too, as in the three states already mentioned, political ideas were already ^ shaping themselves which eventually led to the coalition of 395 b.c.* Pausanias seems to think that the excuse offered by Corinth was dona Jide, but with respect to the Athenians in 397 B.a he adds significantly that though they assigned the present weakness of the state and pestilence as the ground of their inability, the real reason was that they had already got wind of a visit of Conon, the son of Timotheus, to the court of the great king.

This visit is perhaps the key to the whole matter. It is unfortunate that we cannot fix the date of it more exactly. It was brought about by Phamabazus, who as far back as 408 RC, and under the influence in part of Alcibiades, was ready to procure the assistance of Persia for Athens rather than for Sparta. He failed indeed, but only owing to the stronger will and power of Cyrus, who elected for Lysander and Sparta, as narrated in this volume (p. 12 foll.) Again in 404 b.c the same satrap had lent himself to negotiations with Alcibiades, then in exile, the object of which was to further the interests of Athens at the court of Susa, rather than those of Sparta, which it could be shown were already unduly fostered by the rival satrap (or, to give him his proper title, the Karattos Cyrus). This history now repeats itself. It is no longer Alcibiades, but another distinguished Athenian exile, a man of less question-

^ Pausan. iii. 9, 2. 2 And even earlier. ~

■ Which was said to be brought about in part by Persian gold. See the tale of the Rhodian Timocrates sent by Tithraustes, the Persian satrap who succeeded Tissaphemes, and the thirty thousand archers, (The coins were stamped with the image of an archer. )

able patriotism, Conon, at the court of Evagoras, the prince of SaJamis in Cyprus, who conducts the negotiations on the side of Athens; but the satrap is the same.^ Ii^ 397 b.c, as it would appear, if not in 398 b.c summer (see below), during a truce with the Spartan Dercylidas, he repaired to Susa,^ and by dint of a diplomatic correspondence which he set up between the court and the prince of Cyprus, he entirely altered the king’s policy. The correspondence, it seems, was skilfully conducted by Ctesias the king’s physician, and an important item of the new programme was the equipment of a royal navy, the command of which should be entrusted to Conon.^

The prospect of so securing the goodwill of Artaxerxes, though not openly proclaimed, may well explain the reluctance of the Democracy to assist in any joint attack on Persia in 397 B.C. If we turn for a moment to home affairs,* the feeling of the state towards certain wealthy oligarchical members is clear enough from the remark of the historian already quoted. To send off three hundred knights seemed to the ecclesia, even as early as 399 B.a, no bad riddance of bad rubbish ; or to speak more courteously, as Grote says, they were glad to see such people honourably provided for. In either case, it seems certain that between 399 b.c., or even earlier, and 397 b.c, the emancipation of Athens had commenced. As a subject ally of Sparta, and seeing that her walls were still dismantled, she was debarred from independent action, but an instinctive germinal foreign policy existed. This, as regards Hellas

^ For the relations of Phamabazus and Alcibiades in 404, see Grote, H. G. \uU p. 427. For those of Phamabazus and Conon in 397 (or earlier), see Plut. Artax, Ctesias of Cnidos, the court physician, was also diplomatically employed in this matter, as the king’s plenipotentiary. Didot. Ctesiaet fr. 29, § 63 (as preserved by Photius).

2 See Hell. III. ii. i, 398-397 B.a ; winter truce extended through summer, a. ii. 9.

8 See Hell. III. iv. i.

^ For internal affairs at Athens between 403 B.C. and 395 B.C., see among modem authorities, Grote, H. G. viii. ch. Ixvi.; Curtius, iv. p. 142 foll. (Eng. tr. ); Jebb. Attic. Or, voL i., on Lysias, bhA passim; Thirlwall, vol. iv. xxxv. Among ^cient authorities, Xen. Hell. III. ; Lysias, Or, xxxiv., xix., xxvi., xvi., xxxi., XXV., xii., vi, (which is not by Lysias but probably by some contemporary), and xiii. ; Ctesias, his fragments in Didot., and a passage quoted by Plut Artax, (Clough, v. p. 443) ; Pausanias, iii. 9, 2.

proper, pointed in the direction of alliance with Thebes and other states fretting under Spartan predominance. As regards Asia and her former subject allies, it implied a readiness to meet the Persian king half way, in case he showed any desire to retaliate for Cyrus’s attack upon the state which had aided it, whose power he had suicidally developed.

One must not make too much of a small matter; but to return to our biographical difficulty — it seems quite likely that some member of the ecclesia may at any moment after the return of the Ten Thousand have proposed the banishment of that Athenian who had most distinguished himself in the attack on Artaxerxes, whether he was a knight or not, and whatever the colour of his politics before he left Athens in 401 to strike up a quixotic friendship with the bitterest foe of the Democracy (ry ^oXc/AiKWTctTi^), who had proved himself the worst foe also of the Persian king his brother. The conduct of Xenophon on his return to Europe might in itself be easily open to misconstruction. During the two years’ absence he had to a great extent lost touch of home politics ; or he did not allow sufficiently for the conservative reaction at home, and the recovery of national independence. To him the dominion of Sparta appeared to be solidly established ; to the leaders at home it appeared to be assailable. Judging as he did that Sparta was the leading state, and that whatever a Laconian officer willed was law, he had somewhat coquetted with and humoured the navarchs and harmosts with whom he came in contact. It was not through lack of patriotism to his country, but out of loyalty to his fellow-adventurers, that he so adapted himself. It was from an amiable desire to save the reputation of the heroic band, and not their reputation only but their lives, that he so acted. But this action may have been misunderstood or misinterpreted.^ Just as his detractors explained to the Laconian emissaries that he was too much the soldiers’ friend, too popular in his manners, and would prove a thorn in the side of Sparta ; so at home it might have been reported of him that he was too simply philo-Lac6nian. A better citizen would have done better by a fine body of troops than surrender them to Thibron. And what did it all tend to,

^ At the end of the Thracian campaign (see p. 301).

3»>

if not to furthering interests which neither the Democracy approved of, nor the king, whose goodwill was worth conciliating, could be other than annoyed by ?

It was thus, or somehow thus, as I imagine, that on the motion of Eubulus or some other citizen the decree of banishment was passed (between 399 b.c. and 397 b.c) There was certainly no mystery about it at the time ; nor does this view of the matter need any machinery of sycophants to support it. It implies no anti-oligarchic bias in the behaviour of the restored Demos — no overriding of the amnesty — nor indeed anything but what seems natural enough and was already foreseen in 401 B.a by Socrates : a readiness to dispense with the services of so doubtful a citizen.^

The effect of it was to throw Xenophon more completely into the hands of the Spartan authorities, and led eventually to those close relations with Agesilaus, affecting the whole tenor of his future life, which it is now our business to consider.

It has already been suggested that in the spring of 399 b.c, after handing over the remnant of the Cyreians to the Spartan Thibron at Pergamus, Xenophon himself, being free to return home, returned to Europe, possibly to Athens, or more probably no farther than to Megara, where in the society of the Socratics and perhaps of the Spartan Lysander, he may have found time to set his affairs in order, ^ during the space of a month or two, after which he returned to the Aeolid. According to another view, which is quite as probable, he never left Asia at all at this season, but continued in command, actually

^ The offence, such as it was, was the consequence of an original false step, but under the circumstances it may well have been made to appear unpardonable. Friendship with Cyrus, and Laconism I We, too, know the force of political catchwords. We do not know, of course, how the charge was brought against him ; what the procedure, or what the court was. But if he could have pleaded his case, or, better still, if Lysias could have pleaded it for him, we can guess the sort of topics he would have insisted on. He might have urged mutatis mutandis what he urged in the case of Mantitheus, with whose character Xenophon’ s is comparable, that “brilliant, ambitious young Athenian, burning to fulfil the Homeric ideal by distinguishing himself in council as in war ; an Alcibiades made harmless by the sentiment of chivalry.” See Prof. Jebb, Attic Or. vol. i. ch. x. p. 247.

^ E.g, there were his histories, Hellenica A (and the commencement of B [?]) imless already published, and notes for the Life of Socrates, to be attended to.

or virtually, of the six thousand Cyreians, now amalgamated with the Spartan forces under Thibron.

His presence at the scene of action is proved by the minuteness of detail with which he describes the successive campaigns of the following years (summer and winter), and by one or two suggestive phrases, in which he may be supposed to^efer to himself. He had many friends in this part of the world. Here too he found that dearest friend of all, his wife Philesia.^ Xenophon, whatever the date of his arrival, is very much at home in the Aeolid. His friendship with some of the leading families was helpful to the general; but the behaviour of the Cyreians was not altogether satisfactory to the allies, as we discover presently ; and before the end of his term of office Thibron was superseded by Dercylidas (autumn of 399 ^‘C’)f and eventually banished on a charge, preferred against him by the allies, of allowing his troops to pillage their friends. Dercylidas was a very different person. He is graphically described by Xenophon as an inventive and versatile diplomatist, who went by the nickname of Sisyphus.^ He probably received the troops from Thibron in Ephesus in the fall of the year 399 b.c; and at once began to turn to account the well-known jealousy subsisting between the two Persian satraps Tissaphemes and Pharnabazus. Making terms with the former in the south, he proceeded to attack Pharnabazus in the north. Diplomacy and a touch of animosity, since he owed the satrap of Phrygia a personal grudge, dictated this

  • His intimacy with the Greek families descended respectively from Gongylus the Eretriah and Damaratus the ex-king of Sparta is established by what is narrated on pp. 3x6-318 of this volume (Anad. VIH. viii. 8-26), with which should be compared the account given of Thibron’ s prosecution of the war, now that he had received so stalwart an addition to his forces, and aided by the families in question. This is to be found in Hell, III. i. 5, 6. Thibron, who had no desire to cope with the Asiatic cavalry, seems to have clung to the high ground until the arrival of the Cyreians. After that he was free to descend into the plains. Pergamus, Teuthrania, and Halisama, places which belonged to Eurysdienes and Procles the descendants of Damaratus, gave in their adhesion. Gambrium and Palaegambrium, Myrsina and Grynium, were brought over by Xenophon’s friends, the brothers Gorgion and Gongylus (the sons of Hellas) respectively. Others Thibron took by storm, but balking at Egyptian Larissa, (see Cyrop, VH. i. 45), was ordered by the Ephors to march south into Caria (the satrapy of Tissaphemes).

• d^V ^o^^v cTwt /d\a i^tix^-^^^ f *^ ^irciraXetro 5^ S^u^os {flell. HI. i. 8).

L

movement Before the winter of 399 commenced we are back again in the Aeolid. Xenophon is certainly there

> too.^ The dramatic skill of the writer is the chief matter of biographic interest here; and for literary purposes we must bear in mind that the experiences of these years, 399 ac and onwards, will eventually form the material not only for the remaining portions of his HeUemca^ but also for the Cyropae^a and other writings. All these matters, grave or gay, are grist to the author’s mill This cannot be too emphatically insisted on. When and where he found leisure to take notes or pen paragraphs we may conjecture, but cannot positively state.

Thus during these winters, and in the intervals of warlike operations, I can imagine that Xenophon all along found time for study. Here he jotted a note and there he composed a chapter, while for the rest, even on march or in the battlefield he had a clear head and a strong visualising faculty, so that many of the events recorded in his histories are as plainly given as if they had only the day before been written on the tablets of the brain. Vividness — ^that it is which gives the charm to these historical writings. The campaign in the Aeolid of Phamabazus, in which the wily Laconian took eight cities in as many days and reduced Phamabazus to terms, is of this sort.^ So is the next campaign in Bithynian Thrace during the winter of 399-398 B.a, in which we find ourselves once more in company with a contingent of Odrysians sent over by Seuthes. We know this part of the world already,* and the ways of the folk.

The proceedings of the next year (398 b.c) are not less

I graphically told as by an eye-witness ; and here occurlS one of the passages in which Xenophon appears to refer to himself.

’ We are at Lampsacus ; the Spartan commissioners have come

) ^ ” The very circumstantial details which Xenophon gives about the pro-

ceedings of Derkylidas against Meidias in the Troad seem to indicate that he was there .in person” (Grote, H, G. ix. 294).

^ The second part of the Hellenica (i.e. the history of events during 399-

. 387 B.C.) was not finally put into shape for’ several years; and is one of

^ the products, I take it, amongst several others of his Scilluntine leisure. The third part of the Hellenica (387-362 B.c.) was probably put into its final shape at Corinth or possibly at Athens. ’ Hell. III. ii. 1.

  • See Anc^, VI, p. 254 foll., and VII. passim, p. 297 foll. ; HeU, III.

I ii. 2-5.

?

ex SKETCH OF THE

to inform Dercylidas that his term of office is to be prolonged for another year. Reference is made to the late charges against the troops. The commissioners call a meeting of the soldiers and make plain to them the views of the home authorities. Such proceedings would not be tolerated — just dealing by the allies would not be unrewarded. To which the representative of the Cyreians 6 twv Kv/jcoov irpo^o-TqKm makes a nighly Xenophontine answer. ” We,” said he, ” are the same men as we were last year; but we are under a different generaL You need not look further for an explanation.” ^ Dercylidas having renewed the truce with Pharnabazus for the summer, is now off on zn expedition to the Thracian Chersonese.^ He goes through the territory of Seuthes and is hospitably entertained by him. Having fortified the Isthmus * he is presently back again in Asia, and laying siege to Atameus.* This place he reduces in eight months — and garrisons as half-way house, and so returns to Ephesus — at the close of 398 B.a

This winter (398-397 b.c.), again, may well have been spent by Xenophon quietly in Ephesus. It is perhaps the year in which his son (or sons, if twins) was born to him. It was the city, it will be recollected, of Xenophon’s patron divinity. Here was the great temple of Arteniis. Here too lived his friend Megabyzus, the sacristan of the goddess. Hitherto Tissaphernes and Dercylidas had no quarrel; the barbarian and Greek population spent their days in peace. But at this date the Spartan government, urged on by the allies, determined to force the satrap to grant independence to the Hellenic cities. Dercylidas received orders to march into Caria. In combina- . tion with the Spartan admiral Pharax operating by sea, he was to attack Tissaphernes in house and home. The result of this movement on his part was a coalition between the northern

^ Hell, III. ii. 7. See Grote, H, G, ix. 300, 301.

  • Hell, III. ii. 9 ; cf. Diod. xiv. 39 ; see Grote, H. G, ix. 353. It was at this date, the summer of 398 B.C., that Pharnabazus, as I suspect, took the opportunity of paying a visit to the court of Persia. See above, p. cv. ; also Chron, Tables of Greek Hist,, Carl Peter, p. 84 note 163, of Mr. Chawner’s translation.

’ See Anab. p. 232, also p. 81, of this volume.

  • A place occupied by Chian exiles (old friends of the Democracy perhaps), who harry Ionia (Hell, III. ii. 11). The officer left as governor or iirtfieXTiTi^Sf Dracon of Pellene, is named in the Panegyrikos of Isocrates, p. 70.

and southern satraps. The overtures came from Pharnabazus. Though he had Httle stomach for the overlordship of Tissaphemes, who had stepped into the place of Cyrus, he was smarting under the loss of the Aeolid, and entertained decided views as to the propriety of driving the Hellenes — ^that is to say, the Spartans— s-out of Asia.

The campaign of 397 b.c.^ began boldly but was bloodless. Having fortified Caria the two satraps marched towards Ionia. Dercylidas followed. In the valley of the Maeander, which was deep in corn, the army found itself in the presence of the united Persian forces. Our informant has ^ the graphic pen of the war correspondent. Suddenly from a specular mount we sight them — white-shielded Carians,^ and the whole Persian force under arms, with a couple of Hellenic divisions in pay of either satrap, and a cloud of cavalry. The situation is admirably described, as by an eye-witness. While Dercylidas marshals his forces with the precision of a Spartan general, the faint-hearted allies drop their arms in the long corn and run off. Meanwhile Pharnabazus is eager enough to join battle, but Tissaphernes has little hankering to engage with Hellenes ; he has tasted the quality of the C)rreians already, and the rest, he argues, will be like them.^ He sends by preference messengers proposing an interview. ” The wily Spartan gave audience to the envoys in front of a body of picked men (tovs KpariOTOvs ra eiSri rOtvir^pX avrwv koX vmrkiav KoX Tr€^(ov — was Xenophon one of these ?), affected to receive their proposals with indifference, and demanded an exchange of pledges ” ; so Thirlwall, after Xenophon, recounts the scene. Our minds, with Xenophon’s, revert to a similar situation four years previously,^ for so in these trifles history repeats itself. The scenery is sketched with the old familiar touches. When these formalities were concluded, the armies retired for the

1 Hell. III. ii. 12 foU.

  • Here is a personal touch. Xenophon is proud of the C3n*eians. *0 ixivrw. TKrffti^pvTfS t6 t€ Ktfpeiov arpdrevfia KaToKoyi^biJLevoi ws iirdXifirjffev o^rots Kal TO&r<fi ‘jrdPTas vofd^uv 6/jmIovs cTvcu roOs “EXXiycaj oi5k i^affKero fidxcffdou dXXd vifiApas irpds AepKvXldau^ cTveVf 6ti els \6yovs jSoi^Xotro a^(fi &(f>iKia$ai, Hell. III. ii. 1 8 foU.

’ Qearchus’s interview with the king’s envoys on Sept. 6, 401. Anab, II. iii. 3, pp. 124, 125.

night : the Asiatic to Tralles in Caria, the Hellenic to Leucophrys, where was a temple of Artemis most holy, and a sandy-bottomed lake more than a furlong broad, fed by a warm spring of water fit for drinking. The next day Dercylidas demanded the autonomy of the Greek cities; Tissaphemes and Phamabazus the withdrawal of the troops from Asia and the harmosts from the cities. Both parties agreed to report progress; Dercylidas to the home authorities, and Tissaphernes to the king at Susa. There was truce meanwhile.

Here is a lull in affairs, during which the historian pauses also to chronicle the march of events in Europe ^ during the same space of time (401 B.a-397 B.a) He has to recount the coercive measures of Sparta in Elis, and the seizure of the Triphylia ; the accession of Agesilaus, lame in body but whole of spirit, upon the death of Agis; the discovery of grave domestic discord and the conspiracy of Cinadon ; the alarming news of a huge Persian armada, fitting out in Phoenicia, the object of which was unmistakable. This report reached Sparta as it were by accident. A Syracusan master of a merchant vessel (named Herodas), whilst trafficking in those regions, had seen the great galleys collecting and in all stages of equipment.^ The excitement at Sparta was great. The allies were summoned, and war with Persia was resolved upon. The new king, Agesilaus, supported by Lysander,^ who wished to restore his DecarchieSy accepted the duty of leading the host ; and in the spirit of another Agamemnon, started. How he fared at Aulis has already been related.*

Our immediate concern is with the intimacy which presently sprang up between the Spartan king and Xenophon. The two men were mutually drawn to one another. Xenophon, already,

^ Hell, III. ii. 21-31 ; iii., and iv. i. This method of arrangement is significant of a new departure in the style of writing history. In his earlier work he had naturally followed (more or less consistently) the Thucydidean method of chronicling events by summers and winters.

  • See Xenophon’ s description of ” the great Phoenician” in the Economist (viii. 11). The history of the matter is to be found in some fragments of Ctesias preserved by Photius ; and in Diodorus. See Grote, H. G. ix. 354 note; and p. cv., supra, for the persons concerned in planning the alliance between Athens and the king.

5 See his allusion to the Cyreians, Hell. III. iv. 2.

  • And may be read in the pages of Xenophon and Plutarch.

as I believe, in exile (or, if the other view be right, still free to return to Athens), was fascinated by so vigorous a personality.^ The new-comer was not only a Heracleid, a king descended from the loins of kings, but there was that about him which prognosticated the right prince. Perhaps Xenophon admired him the more because of the infirmity of his body, seeing that he had an eager and heroic soul within. As a practical man he fully sympathised with the quest upon which he was sent out. He had long ago discovered how easily the Persian empire might be invaded, and by strategic methods sapped. He had pondered over the problems of its dissolution and absorption. On the other hand, Agesilaus could not but appreciate highly the Athenian — whether or not he had already incurred banishment as an over-zealous admirer of Spartan institutions. With his combined literary and philosophic tastes, his military training and experience, his local knowledge of the country and the character of the Persians and their subject nations, he was exactly the man to keep by his side if possible as his political adviser. Before many months had passed the intimacy was sealed, and from this date onwards (396 b.c), or a little later, we must think of Xenophon not perhaps in command of the Cyreians so much as attached to the staff of the general-in-chief. Cicero speaks of him as the instructor and inspirer of Agesilaus.* In his own more technical phrase he figures, if I mistake not, among the liriKaipiot of the Spartan king. He is one of ” those about him,” and the two became fast friends.

Perhaps at this date one of the minor services rendered by Xenophon to his patron was to help in organising the cavalry.* Whether that particular function devolved on him personally

^ -£.^. as shown in his setting down of Lysander, HeU. III. iv. Agesilaus, even more than the younger Cyrus, is the prototype in Xenophon’s imagination of the “right prince” — Cyrus of the Cyropaedia, Cf. Sidney’s An Apologie for PoetrU, 1595 — “So right a prince as Xenophon’s Cyrus ” (p. 25).

2 Cic de Or. III. xxxiv. Curtius says that he took the place of Lysander when the latter was disgraced. See H. G, (Eng. tr., iv. p. 213), bk. v. ch. iii. That he was no longer in immediate command of the Cyreians, if indeed he had ever held that post officially since March 399 B.C., is proved by the statement in Hell. III. iv. 20.

’ See Hell. III. iv. 14 ; and for his interest in this branch of the service see Hipparch, ix. 9 ; Cyrop, IV. iii. 4 foil, and passim.

may be doubted ; but to his keen interest in the undertaking and sympathy with the spirit of emulation fostered by the * archie ’ man for training regiments of infantry and squadrons of cavalry, and one arm against another arm, we have ample testimony in those pages of the Hellenica which concern the present moment Certain chapters are all aglow with organisation conducted on the competitive principle, and, as I must once more remind my readers, these passages will repeat themselves, sometimes phrase for phrase, in parallel pages of the Cyropaedia, If the separation from his country, and the fading hopes of attaining glory at Athens, and the loss of familiar scenes and faces were a source of deep regret to him, as doubtless was the case,^ there were certain consolations here. “Patria, bonis, amicis, genitoribus abero”; but then he had his wife and children, as we imagine, to visit during leisure. He had many dissolving views of scenery, cities of men and actors upon life’s daily stage, to interest him artistically. There was the excitement of military preparation, there were chance expeditions to whet the soul and nerve the body — and the business of soldiering was relieved by sport.

It is impossible in this sketch to follow the story of Xenophon’s life as minutely as he has given it — since there is scarcely a page of his history for at least ten years which does not reveal some one or other of his experiences or reflections. Indeed, so far as reflections are concerned, the remark applies to the whole of the Hellenica^ and, as I have before said, to most of his writings, the autobiographic transparency of which is extraordinary and leaves no doubt on our minds as to the essential underlying qualities of the writer’s nature : his patient courage, his healthy human-heartedness, his painstaking carefulness, his noble ambition, and his reverential piety.^

It was an early experience of Persian warfare in 396 b.c. which had revealed to Agesilaus the need of cavalry.^ He

^ The terras in which he speaks of exile as one of the great admitted misfortunes of life, seem to show it ; and from the man’s friendly natm-e we must needs divine it.

  • leafyrefda, fpiXapOpuvLa, iTrifUXcLOf 0iXort/Aia, c^i^ia. These are the Xenophontine virtues.

’ In Phrygia, where the Greek cavalry were repulsed by the Persian horse of Pharnabazus near Dascylium, ffeii. III. iv. 13. The prior events may

spent the winter ‘therefore in organising that arm. In the spring of the next year (395 b.c) he collected his whole army at Ephesus, which, in the glowing language of the historian, became a colossal workshop of war.^

At the beginning of the official year Lysander and his Thirty were replaced by Herippidas and his Thirty. One of these officers, named Xenocles, with another unnamed officer,^ was put in command of the cavalry ; another of them, Scythes, commanded the neodamode hoplitesj Herippidas himself the Cyreians (which was apparently a corps cPklite)\ and a fourth of them, Migdon, the contingents from the states. The king warned them (and his voice is the voice of the elder

be briefly summarised thus : Leaving Aulis, Agesilaus sailed to Geraestus, where he collected his forces (thirty Spartans, two thousand neodamodes, and six thousand allies), and thence to Ephesus. Tissaphemes at once demanded why he had come, and was told, to secure the full autonomy of the Greek Asiatic cities. The satrap proposed a truce in order to consult the king, but, with his wonted treachery, took occasion instead to send to the king for a large addition to his forces ; Agesilaus conscientiously adhered to the treaty. In this interval occurred the humiliation of Lysander, who was sent to the Hellespont, and did good service by persuading Spithridates (see Anab, VL v. 7, p. 264, for this officer) to revolt from Phamabazus. Tissaphemes, now reinforced, declared war, unless Agesilaus chose to withdraw from Asia. To this ultimatum Agesilaus replied with a cheerful countenance, yjiy^a, 0atd/xp Tfp irpociinrffi (compare the description of Clearchus in the Anabasis), bidding the envoys to take back his thanks to Tissaphemes for having so secured the hostility of heaven by his perjury, 6ti. iinopKi^as airbs fih iroXcuious Toi>s 0€oi>s iKrfyraro Tois d^ ‘^XKriffi ffvfji^x^^^ ivoiqifeif, and deceiving Tissaphemes by a skilful ruse, marched not upon Caria but into Phrygia.

^ Xenophon’s description glows with enthusiasm. The passage is quoted by Polybius (xii. 20, 7) and others, i^iojf bk km SKi^v t^v fl-^Xiv, iv y 9jVy Oias iTrolTjcep • f| re 7A/) dyoph ^v fieffrij iravToBavG>v Kal tirvtav koX ottXcov

CividJiP ot T€ X<^^0^‘^0*’ l(<^ 0^ T^KTOVeS KoX Ol X<^^^^S /(^ Ol ffKVTOrdflOl Kol

ol ^ur/pd^xM. irajfTes iroXc/ttKA oirXa icare<r/cei5a/‘oi’, &<rT€ r^v irbXiv 6vT(as oieffOai iro\4fiov ipyaar^piov etvcLi. iirepptbffGrj d*Av ris koI iKeivo Idtbv, ‘AyrffflXaop jxh wpQrov, iweiTa W Kcd roifs AXXow (rrportt^aj iffre^vwfiivovs &7rb tQ>v yvjJMoa-lcju dvi&yras Kal dvaTL04yTas toi)s areipdyovs ry ^Apr^pudi. &trov ydp Avdpes Oeoi^s pJ^v aifioiVTOf rd 6^ Tro\€p>iKd dcKoieVf jreidapxeiv 8^ fieXer^ev, ttCIjs oix eUbs ivraOda vdvra pLeffrd iXjrldwv dyo.B(av etpai ; Hell. IIL iv. 16-19.

2 TO&ruv ^yoKXia pJh Kal AXXoi’ ira^ev M rods lirirety, ^K^Orjv Bk iirl rods v€o8afMb8€Ls. tfirXtray, ‘H/)(inrt5ai’ 8* iirl ro^s KvpeiovSf MlyBojya 8k itrl Toi>s dirb tQv TrdXcuw <rrpaTidyraSf Koi vpocTircv a&rois, (hs e^Ods iiyi^oiTo t^v avyTO/Kardrrjv M rd KpdTurra ttjs X^P^^* dinas a&rbdev o(h-<i) rd adypxiTa Kal ripf yv(t>fnjv irapaffKevdj^oiPTO (hs dytavioUfp^voi. Hell, III. iv. 20. Who is meant by SXXov 7 If he was one of the Thirty, why is he not named with the other four oflftcers? Is it possibly Xenophon himself?

Cyrus in Xenophon’s romance) of his intention to march through the roughest districts of the country, in order to whet their souls and bodies against the day of battle, which was not long. And this he did, marching upon Sardis. He met the enemy on the Pactolus, and defeated him. Part of the spoil was some camels, which, the historian tells us, Agesilaus imported into Greece.^ Tissaphernes was in Sardis when the battle took place, and there he met his fate. Accused at Susa of mismanaging affairs, he was superseded by another satrap, Tithraustes, who was sent down with orders to behead him ; and so he died. The new satrap had new terms to oifer to the Spartan king. Agesilaus on his side would do nothing without sanction from the home authorities ; but having got thirty talents from Tithraustes to support his army, he gave him respite, and retired north into the territory of Pharnabazus.

Tithraustes meanwhile, who had grave suspicions that the Spartan had no intention of leaving Asia, but, on the contrary, was cherishing vast hopes of capturing the King himself, resorted to other tactics.

It was now that the Rhodian Timocrates was sent with fifty talents of silver to visit the states of Greece, and so to work upon their leaders as to kindle the flame of war against Lacedaemon. The Rhodian with his thirty thousand * archers ’^ visited Thebes, Corinth, and Argos, not without success. The Athenians, though they would have no share of the gold, were equally eager for the war; vofxi^ovre^ avrwv to apx€iv ” empire belonged to themselves ” — that was their creed. It was thus that the coalition of the allies was cemented, and now that everything was ready, the Thebans, according to the historian,^ set the springs of hostility in motion. The disposition to war they found already existing ; a pretext only was wanting, and this they easily devised. It was to set the Locrians of Opus and the Phocians by the ears. Presently the Thebans

^ See Grote, I/. G. ix. 432 ; and for the use of camels in battle, Cyrop. VII. i. 22, 28, 48 ; Pollux, i. 140.

  • “The coin of Persia is stamped with the figure of an archer,” Plut. Ages. (Clough, iv. 19).

^ So Thirlwall (vol. iv. p. 391) after Xenophon, Hell. III. Cf. Grote, ix. 397-408, and Curtius, bk. v. iv. (vol. iv, 221-224, Eng. trans.) for their views of the Phocian war.

LIFE OF XEXOPHOX aril

found themselves in the position of champions deSending the LocrianSy and Spaita the Phodans. Either state was really anxious to fly at the othei^s throat The Laconians had not foigotten how the Thebans had claimed a tithe of the spoil dedicated to Apollo in the Decdeian war ; nor, yet again, how they had not only refused to join in the expedition against Piraeus (in B.C 403), but had induced the Corinthians to refuse also ; nor, last of all, their late afiront to King Agesilaus at Aulis. Indeed they thought the moment oppoitune, and rushed hastily into war, sending Lirsander into Phods. Here that officer was to raise forces and march upon Haliartus, where Pausanias, the Spartan king, was to join him with the Peloponnesian forces by a certain day. Lysander carried out his conunission to the letter. He went £uther : he Ixougfat over Orchomenus. Pausanias the while was collecting his forces at T^ea.

The Thebans, finding that they were to be invaded by a Laconian army, sent an embassy to Athens. Their speech does great credit to the envoys and to Xenophon’s historic imagination.^ It was a delicate matter for a Theban to address the ecdesia at Athens. There were many ancient prejudices to be overcome and painful recollections to be effaced. The orator begins with the most poignant of these : the attitude of Thebes at the end of the great war, when they had proposed to wipe Athens off the face of Hellas. But that was not the vote of a free constitutional city, it was the wicked design of a single man ; whereas on a later and happier occasion, when they had refused to march upon Piraeus, the whole city passed that resolution. It was their conduct then which had brought down upon them the wrath of Sparta now. He presses the claim of obligation home on the city party and on the Democracy in tmn. He kindles their imaginations by appeals to the well-known ambition of the city to recover empire.

”When we and you are standing shield and shield together (<rw€unriSovvT€s), be sure the enemies of Sparta will spring up by thousands on every side. Laconians are hated everywhere — by Argos of old, by Elis in modem times.

1 HelL III. V. 8-15. ” The speech of the Theban envoys sets forth strikingly the case against Sparta as it then stood.” Grote, H. G. ix 405.

Corinthians, Arcadians, and Achaeans, one and all, like ourselves, detest them for good reasons. We are tired of fighting their battles and receiving no share of the reward of toil. They appoint their helots ^ as harmosts, and now in the day of their success belord it over their allies, who are after all free men. No set of people have suffered more than your own subject allies, who clutched at liberty and have embraced a twofold slavery. They lie between the upper and the nether millstone of the harmost and Lysander’s Decarchy. And what of the great king who contributed the heaviest item towards your overthrow ? With him it fares to-day no better than if he had supplied Athens instead of Sparta with the sinews of war. Now then is your opportunity. Put yourself at the head of all these victims of Spartan injustice, and you will regain your empire. You will more than regain it. Athens will be the mistress not of a maritime force only as of yore, but of all of us. We, and the Peloponnesians, and your former subjects, and the king himself with his vast armament, will follow your leadership. We were staunch allies to Sparta in the past How much more staunch shall we be to Athens now when we are fighting, not for islanders, or Syracusans, or other foreigners, as in the late war, but for ourselves who have suffered foul wrong ! Your empire crumbled ; how much more readily will this fabric of selfishness called Sparta fall to pieces ! Your empire was based on a naval power, which they lack. Theirs is a system of selfish dominance, the tyranny of a handful of people exercised over numbers equally well armed. Now is your time, men of Athens. We summon you to a fortune far happier for Athens even than for Thebes.” The assembly unanimously voted the alliance, and that too in spite of the fact pointed out by Thrasybulus to the envoys, that Athens lay midway between the belligerents with dismantled walls. ^ But they had not forgotten the debt of gratitude due to Thebes during the troubles of the Thirty. They would run the risk.

Into the history of this campaign I need not enter. Lysander was slain at Haliartus ; Pausanias arrived too late,

^ Compare with this indictment Xenophon’s own strictures on the degeneracy of Sparta in the appendix chapter to his Laconian Polity^ xiv. 3 Hell, III. V. i6.

and in the face of the united forces of Thebes and Athens, presently fell back. The feeling of irritation at Sparta vented itself on Pausanias, who, being condemned to death, retired to T^ea. His son Agesipolis succeeded to the throna

To return to Agesilaus and Xenophon. The autumn campaign of 395 B.C. in Asia was directed against Pharnabazus and Phrygia. At the suggestion of Lysander’s friend Spithridates,^ who undertook to introduce the native ruler of the country to the Spartan, it was extended to Paphlagonia.^ To bring over one of the nations subject to the great king was much to the taste of Agesilaus. The interview was most successful The independent chieftain Otys was quite ready to make an alliance. Thereupon to reward Spithridates for his services, and to strengthen Spartan interests in Asia, Agesilaus, with a diplomacy worthy of Xenophon’s ” archie ” man,* set himself to negotiate a match between King Otys and the daughter of Spithridates. The details are given in Xenophon’s romantic manner, and remind one of the Cyropaedia, So does the scenery of Dascylium, Pharnabazus’ residence, now occupied by the Spartan king, with its parks and forests abounding in game of every kind. Here in winter quarters lay the army comfortably, and Xenophon, we may be sure, found time for sport * (there was hunting, fishing, and fowling to be had), as also for literary exercises and meditations.

1 See above, p. cxv. This must certainly, I think, be the officer mentioned in Anab. VI. v. 7, p. 264.

  • This independent chieftain, here called Otys (and in the Ages. iii. 4, ” Cotys ”), seems to bear a striking resemblance to Corylas in the Anab. V. iv. 8, p. 229. Here it is said of him, koX ydp KoXot/fiofos inrb paffiX^us ovk dvaPep-ZlKei, Hell. IV. i. 2 ; there the words are koX vOv oStoi (the Paphlagonians) oi Trapeyivovro poffiXeT KaKodyrif dXXd /jlcTJ^ov tftpoveZ 6 6.px^^ airruv. That was in 400 b.c Within five years the chief may have changed, but not the independence of the people.

» Hell. IV. i. 4 foll. So the “archie” man, the “right prince” of the Cyrop., is a great matchmaker.

  • Kal B^fKU al fUv koI iv irepicipyfiivoii Tapadeiffois, at Si Kal dyairexTafjJvois rbvoiSy ird7«a\at. irepiippei 5i Kal Trorafibs Tayrodairuv IxO^nav irMifnii, ^ di Kal tA irrrivd, &</>dova rois 6pvi.dev<rai dwafiivoiSf Hell. IV. i. 15. If only he had mentioned the particular fauna of the district and the methods of fowling 1 Hell. IV. i. 15 foll. Dascylium is on the Propontis (Sea of Marmora). A modern traveller quoted in Murray’s Turkey in Asia, 1878, p. 134, says : ’ ’ The fauna of Olympus is also rich. Roe-deer and wild boar are very abundant ; red-deer are also found, together with foxes, jackals, and

It was not all play, however, for the satrap, ousted from house and home, was ever ready to pounce upon marauding parties, or gave occasion himself for some deed of emprise. Scene upon scene, these incidents of the campaign present themselves. It is like turning over the leaves of an artist’s note-book ; or, more truly, these are finished sketches -illustrative of the matter in hand, which will by and by themselves be turned to new account as the material of more elaborate compositions. And what a ripple of sunny gladness plays over these leaves! what joy in mere living they reveal ! what a merry-go-round of soldierly adventure ! what an absolute freedom from ennui ! what contrasts 1 The gipsy life of the roving Persian satrap ; the brilliant raid of Herippidas ; the sudden departure in dudgeon of Spithridates and his Paphlagonians.^ The crowning scene is an interview between Agesilaus and the satrap.^ It was arranged by a certain Cyzicene Greek named Apollophanes, an old friend of the satrap’s and a new friend of the king’s. The trysting- place was a grassy mead, where Agesilaus and his Thirty lay outstretched on the sward awaiting the arrival of Pharnabazus, who appeared ere long in magnificent golden apparel. His courtiers and attendants began to lay down carpets and cushions for their lord. But the satrap was too well bred to indulge in displays of luxury as if in contrast with Spartan simplicity. He too, without more ado, reclined upon the greensward. The interview is dramatically conducted in the historian’s favourite manner. It is also a chapter in political diplomacy. The language used by Pharnabazus brought a blush to the cheeks of those over-aggressive Spartans. It is impossible not

wolves. Eagles, of more than one species, were constantly in sight Vultures are occasionally met with, and the red-legged partridge, quail, and woodcock are abundant.” The whole description of the hunting-grounds, parks, and open country has its parallel in the Cyropaedia, It was here, too, as well as on the field of Cunaxa, that Xenophon made the study of Scythian chariots (§ 7), which he elaborated into the monograph on the subject in Cyrop, VI. t 52 foll.

^ To complete the story — these barbarians could not understand the regulations of the Spartan quartermaster-general touching spoil. So off they went to throw in their lot with Ariaeus, who had also, it seems, revolted from the king. Hell. IV. i. 26 foll.

2 lb, IV. i. 29-38. Apollophanes is another of the “go-betweens.” See above.

to admire the courteous independence of the Persian. Our . sympathies are touched. Like Agesilaus, we are ready to f grasp the satrap’s hand and assure him of our warmest regard. Surely Xenophon was seated there amongst the Thirty, if not of them. To the more serious business there is a pretty afterscene — the seal of reconciliation between king and satrap .^

It was about the beginning of spring in the year 394 B.C. when, in accordance with his promise to Pharnabazus, the Spartan king withdrew from Phrygia. Reaching Thebe’s plain, he encamped in the neighbourhood of the temple of Artemis of Astyra, and began collecting a numerous host from all sides. His preparations were made with a view to marching up as far as possible into the heart of the Persian dominions, and in the progress of this march he reckoned on being able to detach one nation after another from the king.

What hold such a project must exercise on the minds of those concerned, and on Xenophon in particular, we can well imagine. Some years later,^ when the hegemony of Sparta was scarcely more widely admitted than at this season, the democratic orator Lysias urged at Olympia the duty of pan- Hellenic combination against the tyrant of the west, Dionysius, and the tyrant of the east, Artaxerxes. At a later Olympic festival Isocrates in his Fanegyrikos still more elaborately argued in favour of an attack on Persia, which ancient wrongs and present opportunity alike demanded. ” If for Hellas’ sake our fathers rallied against Troy, ought not an insult to

^ See Grote, H. G. ix. 387. All these intemunciatory stories reveal a side

of Greek character (I scarcely like to think of Xenophon’ s own character, and

( yet he has a touch ‘of it) which I hardly know how to name. I fear the word

” flunkeyism ” must be uttered. In us, at any rate, the thing I am aware of

I would amount to f!unke3rism ; and in the Alexandrian period there is no doubt

’ about it. There is flunkeyism ad nauseam there. Xenophon and his friends

^ are saved by the grace and obvious dignity of the narrative. They do not

f sacrifice their own liberty of action ; but whether for artistic purposes or

because he feels the glamour of orientalism, he surrounds his archie man (be

it Agesilaus or C)nrus the Great) with too many scraping courtiers and nodding

satellites, in too oriental a fashion, d&j ye ifiol 5ok€T, See Cyrop. passim,

\ 2 Either 384 B.C., as Grote {H, G, x. 103 note) and others think, or in the

preceding 01)mfipiad, 388 B.C., which is Prof. Jebb’s view. See his reasons

for accepting this as the date of the Olympiakos of Lysias {Attic Orators, i. 204

note 2. The date of Isocrates’ Panegyrikos is undoubtedly 380 B.C., I think ;

k op. cit, vol. ii. ch. xvi. p. 150 foll. I have freely availed myself of Prof. Jebb’s

\ analysis of both speeches.

Hellas to kindle a war now — a. war which will move forward, not liable to repulse, but with the stately progress of a sacred embassy?” This was in 380 ac. Fourteen years previously Agesilaus was looking forward to a march moving forward not liable to repulse ; and he had good reasons for so prognosticating. He chanced also to have with him the best authority on such a matter in the person of Xenophon himself, who could tell him in plain terms (what the Olympic orator did not fail to introduce as the climax of his argument), the inherent weakness of Persia. ” Some stand in awe of his strength. Were he indeed strong that would be but another reason for attacking him before he is stronger. But he is not strong.” Xenophon might have anticipated the very language of the orator. ” I pass over the successes against Persia of Dercylidas, of Dracon, of Thibron, of yourself Agesilaus. Nor is the mettle of the Persian troops better than the quality of Persian generalship. This was well seen in our own case who accompanied Cyrus. After the loss of our leaders, surrounded by difficulties of every kind, we effected our retreat as smoothly as if the Persian force, which sought to harass it, had been a guard of honour. Chastised when he invaded Europe, defeated on the seaboard of Asia, the Persian king has actually been mocked under the walls of his own palaces.”^ To the Greeks the practicability of the idea was now for the first time demonstrated. Its fascination needs no demonstration to ourselves. To attack the Barbarian was incumbent as a sacred duty, not only because he was the natural and common foe of Hellas, but for the unifying of the states of Hellas. So it appeared as an unselfish project which appealed directly to men’s consciences, and might at times be preached as a crusade.^ Sooner or later it must be realised ; but the glory of its fulfilment was denied to Agesilaus,^ and to him who was partly the inventor of it — Xenophon.*

^ See Anab. II. iv. 4, p. 129.

^ The parallel is so far tenable, in that the crasades were directed against the common foe of Christendom and tended to the unification of the nations of Europe.

’ Denied also to Jason of Pherae and to Philip, its realisation was, as all the world knows, reserved for Alexander. See Bacon’s remark, supra, p. xx.

< See Plut. Ages. (Clough), iv. 10, 21, 23, 35, 40, for Xenophon’s relation to the Spartan king.

Just when the march was about to be commenced, Epicydidas arrived from Sparta with the message of recall. Xenophon admires the Spartan discipline with which the king turned and obeyed He is sorry for him. But in some respects he was himself the more to be pitied. Once more the chance of doing something which should redound to his honour was stolen from him. There was in his case also a deeper calamity attending the change of programme. To follow Agesilaus homewards, in whatever capacity he went, was a double disaster. It was to run more than the ordinary risk of life, which was perhaps of little consequence ;^ and it involved, further, his appearance in the field of battle in opposition to his own countrymen.

If, as I suppose, he was already banished, possibly he had but little choice of action. All we know about the matter is from his own lips in a single passage. ^ It is not even plain, though an obvious inference from that passage, that he was present at Coronea. Plutarch (and it is only what any one else would be inclined to do) somewhat expands the remark, ” Xenophon, w/u? was present and fought on Agesilaus^ side J reports it to be the hardest fought battle that he had seen.” Xenophon’s own description of the battle, it must be added, reads like that of an eye-witness, and for compressed force of language is a masterpiece of word painting often quoted by the ancient writers.*

But the fact of his presence is one thing, the moral question another. In reference to this double problem I have little to say, except that I believe he was present, and not improbably in arms. He may have been in command of a division of cavalry, or he may have been simply attached to

^ We may fairly credit Xenophon, who was not so much philo-Laconian as a man cast in Dorian mould, with the desire to live and die i)i K&KKiffTO. (see Anab, passim). According to the epitaph of Plut. Pelop. (Clough), ii. p. 202 —

” They died, but not as lavish of their blood, Or thinking death itself was simply good ; Their wishes neither were to live nor die, But to do both alike commendably.”

^ Anab, V. iii. 6, p. 218, compared with Plut. Ages. (Clough), iv. p. 21. 3 Hell, IV. iii. 15 foll., especially § 19. Cf. Longinus, ircpL fh/zovs, § 19. Xenophon himself repeats it in Cyrop, VIII. i. 38.

the staff of the general and performing the duty of an adjutant. In either case had he been taken prisoner it would have gone hard with him. Wherever he was, he was a keen observer of the fighting ; but he unfortunately does not mention as an eyewitness or from hearsay what part his own countrymen played. He merely tells us that they were posted in front of Herippidas and the foreign brigade, including, I suppose, the Cyreians. It is significant that he entered into private life soon after, unless perhaps for a few years he continued to attend Agesilaus on some of his campaigns. It is further noticeable that no word of reproach in reference to his conduct on that day is raised against him by any ancient writer, contemporary or other ; nor does any word drop from his lips in sign of an evil conscience. Yet it is he who has said some of the noblest things ever said touching the duty of a citizen to the state. Nor do I think that his share in the wider if more visionary sentiment of pan -Hellenic patriotism can be urged in explanation of his conduct, since, though doubtless he was strongly swayed by it, he was not of so dull a wit that he could fail to distinguish between one duty and another. Nor again was he, nor could he feel himself to be, justified as an exile fighting for reinstatement, or for the subversion of a pernicious government, de facto but not dejure dominant at home. He was not in the position of a follower of Hippias at Marathon, or of the Duke of Berwick at the Boyne, or of a French ‘emigre noble in ‘93. He could not possibly excuse himself by casuistical arguments suited to the later circumstances of mercenary generalship. The difficulty in which he was involved was not the result of a private connexion by marriage with a Seuthes or a Cotys. He was not in like case with some free-lance captain who, on a sudden turn of politics, should find himself in the employment of his country’s enemy, the other day its friend.^ The difficulty in

^ The story of Charidemus would be illustrative were his not an exceptional case amongst the condottieri of those times. That of Iphicrates, taking part with his father-in-law Cotys and actually fighting against Athens, is more apt. See Demos, c. Aristocr. p. 664, § 153, MX^iTicev inrkp rCov K6ruos irpayfidruv ivavTia roii iz/MT^pas aTparriyms vavftax^iv. Grote, H. G. x. 410 ; Curt. H. G, V. 103, Eng. trans. ; Rehdantz, Fit, Jphic, Chabr, Timoth. Atkeniensium, V. §§ 7, 8.

Xenophon’s case was in some sort exceptional, and the explanation of his behaviour obvious. In no case was his offence so heinous but that before the end of his days the sentence of exile was rescinded. This only happened indeed when the “Boeotian” party at Athens had lost and the “Laconian” party had regained its power. At that date (possibly in 369 b.c) Xenophon was not only reinstated legally, but was evidently regarded by his fellow-citizens as one whom they could well afford to be proud of. But concerning this matter, not more obscure indeed than it was unhappy, enough has been said. The reader will form his own conclusion.^

Agesilaus was wounded in the battle of Coronea, and taken home to Sparta. Thither Xenophon evidently, as I think, accompanied him, and with him there stayed for the next few years (between 394 b.c and 389 b.g, or even so late as 387 B.C., the year of the peace of Antalcidas). He probably accompanied Agesilaus on more than one campaign in this interval. He seems to have been with him during the expedition into Corinth 2 (392 or 391 B.C. ?), and at Peiraeum, when the news of the destruction of the mora by Iphicrates was brought Possibly he was with him also the following year in Acarnania. There is the same minuteness of detail and vividness of description now and again in his chronicle of these years, which we have noted as a proof of the historian^s presence at the scene of action in Asia.*

The two incidents of chief biographical importance for

^ If he takes Grote’s view he will probably subscribe to the verdict of Niebuhr, ” Xenophon was not a good citizen,” albeit in other respects KdWurr6t T€ KoX &pt,<rTos. For myself, I regard him as to some extent (how far it is impossible to say) a victim of circumstances. I also admit that the web in which he was eventually caught was very much of his own weaving. Fact Its descensus: the fault was greatest when the act was slightest. He ought never to have joined Cyrus, the enemy of his country, on a wild-goose chase after glory. But how, being what he was, could he at that date have resisted the temptation? and how could any one, except perhaps Socrates, have foreseen the mischief which would come of it ? The remark in the Memorabilia comes back to us : ” But those who refused to listen to his warning lived to repent of their obstinacy.” It is not the fashion of these Greeks to speak of personal joys and sorrows. He had too much xaprepla to bemoan his misfortune.

2 //el/. IV. iv. 19 ; IV. v. 2 ; IV. vi. 6 foll.

’ See above, p. cviii. foll.

this whole period are now to be named The first of these has indeed been already discussed in detail in a former footnote— the latter has been more than once referred to. It was during his sojourn at Sparta, as Plutarch tells us, that at the instance of Agesilaus the exiled philosopher was persuaded to send for his children, and had them educated in the lore of Spartan chivalry. That is the first point. The second is that at a certain date — perhaps before, and probably not later than, 387 b.c. — he was sent as a colonist to Scillus by the Laconians, in appreciation of his services, and eventually presented with a house and farm.^ Scillus was one of the Triphylian townships which had been taken from Elis in 400 B.C., where the donors evidently wished to have some trusty person with a head upon his shoulders, to represent their interests. No doubt, in return for the gifts of leisure and security the new resident was expected to play the part of proxenos or consul to the Spartans. In both of these opportunities so presented to him the philosopher is to be deemed happy. The first enabled him to bring up his children in what he probably regarded as the best education to be had in Hellas ; the other to write his books. ^

It was doubtless at Sparta that he collected facts and formed reflections, the fruit of which is to be found not only in the Laconian Polity (an immediate product of his sojourn in the capital), but in those other political’ studies, the Hiero and the Cyropaedia, His mind was set working more definitely than before on the question of government (what is an Q^yj\ ?), and these are his answers. The Hiero probably did not find expression until the author had witnessed the remarkable scene

1 See Diog. Laert Life of Xen. § 8. ivreOBev IfKOev els r^v ”^\Kd^a fierii, ’ Ayri<ri\dov KcxXifffjuhov els rhv wpbs Orj^alovs irdXefiw ’ Kcd airrQ, Trpo^eviouf idwrav ol AaKc5cuft6vioi • ivrevOeVf ideas rbv ‘AyrjaCXaw IJKev els ^KiXKoGvTa … d^KOfiivov d^ rod Meya^i^fl^ov Kurd irpdi/xurty t^ vayriy6peu)s, KOfiurd/JLCPOs rd %pi^juara x^^P^o” i’^rplaro koX Kodiiponre r^ Qetp … ^i^o-t $’ 6 Aelyapxos Sri kcU olxlay Kcd dypbv a^tfi (5o<rap AaKedaifJuSvioi, Cf. Paus. v. 6, 5. AaKehoLfibvioL Ik Harepw ^KiXXovvra dirorefiSfieyoi r^f ‘HXe/as !Sevo<avTL idwrca^ t^ Fpt^XXov jc.t.X.

2 See Plutarch, de Exilio, p. 603 B. irola iftvya^iK^ pijiros oAk f^<m trkarvripa r^s ^KiWovvrLas X^P^^t ^^ V Sevo^w fierd tV (rrpareiav ip \nrap6p elde yijpas ; ti, p. 605 C. QovKvdiSris <rwiypa//€ rhv iriiKe/xov riab IleXoirovyTifflonf Koi ‘AOrivcUup hf Qpjxjj irepl ttjv Zicairr^v (JXiyy ’ ^€vo<p&v h SwXXoOi’Tt T^s*HXc(oj.

described by Lysias in his Olympian when the tyrant Dionysius, in the person of his brother, sent a magnificent thedry to the famous festival, and drew down upon himself the sarcasm of the great democratic orator.^ The Cyrop<udia was not penned for many a day yet, and is evidently a composition of a novel order, upon which the writer expended much pains, meaning it to embody his theory that the secret of apx^ is the discovery, as the result of parentage and education, of the right prince or archie man. But with this work, so often referred to in the pages of this sketch, we have nothing especially to do at present The Laconian Polity is interesting as containing a quasi-historical account of Lycurgus’s institutions, as seen or pictured in their more or less ideal working, along with a severe criticism on the practical breaking-down of these institutions in modem Sparta.^ It is to Xenophon that we owe the truly fine phrase, “They magnify themselves on their lowliness ” — t<^ raTrcivol ctvat /icyaAvvovrai, which has the very ring of a magnificat Such was the spirit in which he wished his boys to be brought up, so that they might become adepts in the art of self-discipline and leadership, to a/ox^tv t€ koX apx^o-Oai, since that was the gist of the whole matter. The beginning and end of Doric or Spartan education, it tallied or complemented that other Attic or Ionic principle in which Xenophon himself had been excellently trained, that a man should be able to speak and to act, Aiyciv t€ koI irpaTr^iv SvvaxrOai. As to his two sons, they grew up to be good citizens. One of them, the elder (Gryllus), died fighting for his country in behalf of his own state and his father’s adopted state — Athens and Sparta — at the battle of Mantinea.’ The younger came out of the battle

^ This was either in 388 or 384 B.C. See note above, p. cxxi.

3 The epilogue of the Cyropaedia (VIII. viii.), if written by Xenophon himself, is exactly analogous with the strictures passed on Spartan institutions in those degenerate days which are to be found in chapter xiv. of Lac. Pol. How this chapter, which I hold to be genuine, came to be inserted into the text at this particular point of the treatise, is a question into which it is not opportune to enter at present. It was probably of later date than the bulk of the essay, and should appear as a note, or in appendix. Both criticisms read like the palinode or liberavi animam of a writer who finds the world he has tried to idealise not after all so very good — the sigh of a dissatisfied demiurge.

  • Or rather, the cavalry skirmish of the day before. See Hell. VII. v. ig, z6, 17. a.irr(a» d^ dwiSavop AvSpes dyadol (he is writing his own son’s epitaph) Kal diriicrciyav di dvXw dri TotoiJroi/s.

unscathed. But this is to anticipate the evil day, which was also the day of glory and renown, by many years. Before they left Sparta the boys were probably of an age to play football and to go hunting excursions with the other young Spartans ; ^ and we may guess, from their appellation, these great twin brethren were quite at home, and favourites. Their father is silent of course concerning his own domestic life and literary occupations.^ Of the latter I have already spoken. The former we are left to gather from the many passages in which he lovingly depicts the joys and sorrows, the sunshine and April showers, of boyhood,^ and the sophrosyne (crcD</>/ooo-vvr/) of womanhood. He might well have written a special treatise on boyhood — a. prose poem, in that sweet style of his own, anticipative of /‘art d^itre grand-phre. He did write, as is well known, a treatise which might have been entitled On Wifehood — the Economist^ which Albert! * (or some other of those times) used to depict the life of a good citizen, founded on masserizia^ piety, and good sense. Perhaps we need not go farther to assure ourselves of Xenophon’s own private happiness than to this idyll of married life, the delicate domesticity^ of which is truly touching. This was a peace which no exile could rob him of, and which was

^ See MuUer’s Dorians^ vol. ii. p. 309. •’ During the progress from the condition of an ephebus to manhood, the young Spartans were called Sphaercis, probably because their chief exercise was football, which game was carried on with great emulation, and indeed resembled a battle rather than a diversion. In their nineteenth year they were sent out on the crypteia,” etc. The two boys would be brought up as TpdiptjJLOi.

^ If not finished some years ago, the first part of the Hellenica (Bks. I. and II. to speak roughly — see Note C) perhaps belongs to this date, and was finished in Sparta.

^ Cyrop, passim. For Vart d’itre grand-ph-e, see Cyrop, I. iv., Astyages and his little grandson. One cannot help thinking of Xenophon and his two sons, whilst reading the passages on brotherly affection in the Memorabilia, II. iii. I foll., and Cyrop. VIII. vii. 13 foll. As to the sophrosyne of woman, see Cyrop. passim. Hejnvood has put two of these — Panthea, the wife of Abradatas, and Tigranes’s wife — into his VwiUK^ov (pp. 126-244 of the edition of 1624). There are many others, historical or purely imaginary, sketched in a manner worthy of Euripides or of the painter Zeuxis himself.

  • Alberti wrote also in exile. See for the influence of Xenophon’ s Oeconomicus on Italian writers, Mr. Symonds, Italian Lit, Part I. p. 196 note,

^ Cf. Cyrop, VII. v. 56 for the secret of Xenophon’s happiness — ” Home, sweet Home” — and the keystone of his philosophy.

independent of locality. He could find it alike in Europe and in Asia : Sparta, Scillus, Corinth in turn fostered it. It was, as far as any earthly joy may be, perdurable.

If indeed anything of a more external character were needed to enhance it, that additional element was to be found in the quietude of Scillus.^ The lovely scenery of the place itself, to this day lovely ; the delicious atmosphere ; the rare combination of mountain, wood, and stream ; the opportunity for sport; the horses and the dogs ;2 the farmstead and its daily round of occupations ; the household and its inmates, with their varied interests; the neighbouring townships and local politics ; the proximity to Olympia ; the recurring season of festival ; the stream of visitors ; the pleasures of hospitable entertainment; the daily family sacrifices at the hearth or before the cedar image of the great goddess Artemis in her model temple — these things, and, above all, the serene satisfaction of literary labour, combined to form an enviable sum total of sober happiness during many years.

Middle Age, 387 (or 389)-37i B.c. circa j At Scillus; Intellectual Floruit, Great Literary Period.

It is not certain at what date the family migrated to Scillus, nor at what precise date was disestablished ; but

1 See map; also Baedeker’s Greece, p. 315, and Xenophon’s own description, p. 218 of this volume. It is appropriate here to quote the words of Themistius (see p. xx. of Introduction). That writer, like Cicero and the ancients in general, fully believed in the genuineness of the Agesilaus (as to which I will state my views in a later volume). He says {Or. 2, p. 27 d) * Ky^aOsojov 5^ otda t6v pacnX^a ttjs ^Trdfyrrjs &n ^affxfHav o^k &kv€i iTraiveiu Kal &fJLelfi€(rdai yuoLKpQ §L^\l(fi (or does the orator refer to Hellenica B, rather than the iyK<a/jdov itself?) iireid^ ain-<^ v4fi€<r0ai 5i€irpd^aT0 x^f^^^ ”^^ /*€ra^i)”HXi5os koX ‘ApKadLaSf ov Tr6pp<a ^kiWoOvtos iy t^ <P^V’ — ^^ f^^ ^^^^ V X^P”^ oiJLoLd dypbv ipyd^€(rdai irpoiKa ‘ApKadiK&Uf ij iiraLvov rux^‘^v dyi^poj re Kcd dOavdrov ’ ra^a 5’ Av koX a^ris 6 ‘ApxtSd/jiov rifudyrepov j^vvitprq etvcu t^s aifTov dcjpeSis rb x^P’-^‘^P^^ ””^^ ^€vo<p^yTos ’ t6 fikv ydp X670S ^v vrrb ipiKoadipov yeypafifiivos, ij d^, et tl dei irpoa^eip ry e/Xry^^rt, irvpol Kal KpiQaX KoX rptaicrd <bpcua koX dopKdSai Kod (rOs diojKeiv re kcU dKOvri^cLV.

  • For the horses and dogs, see Xenophon’s two tracts, the Sportsman (Cynegetica), perhaps a youthful work ; and that on Horsemanship, a work of his old age. Pollux the grammarian (v. 47) says he had a dog named Hippocentaur — cf. Cyrop. IV. iii. 17 ; Aelian V, H. 9, 39. For the farming occupations, see the Economist,

there, amid those loveHest surroundings of nature, and within easy reach of the sacred city, they lived, we must assume, for fifteen or probably twenty years. There the boys grew up to manhood, properly trained for war by yearly hunting expeditions. There let us believe that Philesia, being still alive, played a part like that of the wife of Ischomachus,^ finding happiness in manifold co-operation with her husband; the wife, the mother, the kindly mistress of the house, befriending her servants, and beloved of all.^ There, at all events, the father, whose character was fully formed, spent his time between healthy bodily and mental exercises, ” in hunting,’* as his biographer has toldus,^ “and entertaining his friends, and writing his histories.” Here certainly he attained his literary prime.*

A large number of his writings (at least as finished compositions) probably date from this period. Others were in process of composition, and had reached various stages of completion, before Xenophon was forced to change his residence. Both sets may appropriately be named in order here. They are the specially Socratic writings, including the Memorabilia^ the Economist^ and the Symposium^ which are all closely connected — the Economist being, as I have above suggested (see Note B, p. liv.), an expanded chapter of the Memorabilia^ but as a finished composition, perhaps the earliest of the three. With these, as a product of the Scilluntine leisure, we must include the Hiero^ the nature and occasion of which admirable dialogue have already been noticed. It is worth noting perhaps, as a point of biographic interest, that the proximity to Olympia enabled Xenophon to keep in some sort of touch with the world of letters. He may well have listened to the very speech of Lysias above referred to, and, at a later date, to the Panegyric of Isocrates. These oppor-

^ ” She is to be like the queen bee in her hive,” ^ h rf ffijjpfu ^e/ubi’ fiiXiTTa (poetry anticipating science in this pretty illustration), Oecon. vii. 17.

  • Ih. vii. 37 ; cf. Eurip. Ale, 192 foll. ; Browning, Balaustion’s Adventure , P- 38. ^ ^

5 ToivrevOep dieriXcL KVPrjyeTCjv Kcd roifs tfUXovs iariwv Kal tAs Urroplas <Fvyy pdifxav, Diog. Laert. Life of Xenophon, § 9.

  • He must, if born about 431 B.C., have been between forty and fifty when he came, and about sixty when he left.

tunities were not likely to be wasted. The last writing, which almost certainly belongs in the same sense to this period, is the Laconian Polity,

This list of finished, and possibly published, works does not, as already stated, exhaust the literary labours of the period During the sixteen or eighteen years in question (from 389 or 387 B.C. to 371 B.C.) the author, it would seem, had two or three of his larger works still on hand, though at various stages of completion. Thus the Anabasis^ if for the greater part written, was not published in its final form till after 371 B.c, or even later.^ The second part of the Hellenica^ containing a record of Hellenic affairs from the year 403 b.c. to 387 B.c, was in the same way probably ripe for publication before Xenophon left Scillus ; while whatever his method of composition may have been, the author was certainly employed in collecting notes for the final portion of the same historical work ^ during the whole of his residence in Scillus. Besides which we may suppose that he was always in some sense working at and meditating scenes and chapters for his historico-philosophical romance, the Cyropaedia, Possibly he had made some advance with the composition as a whole. The publication (or completion), however, of these four larger, and of his remaining minor works * can be clearly referred to a later period, when his happy residence at Scillus was a bygone.

If we are right in our conclusions, that residence was discontinued in the year so disastrous to the arms of Sparta on the field of Leuctra (b.c. 371), and for reasons closely connected with that historical event.

^ As proved by internal evidence deducible from Anab, V. ill. p. 218 foll. See above, p. Ixvi.

^ Hellenica i?=Bk. III. i. i (or perhaps more strictly, II. iii. 11) to V.

i. 36.

3 Hellenica C”=Bk. V. ii. to the end of Bk. VII. (387 B.C. -362 B.C.) The process of collecting notes for this work at Scillus, broken off in 371 B.C., was resumed at Corinth, and occupied the author till the end. The book was still on hand in 359 B.C. See above.

  • The Cynegetica was possibly already published ; the Lac. Pol. probably at Scillus. The remaining minor works are the Hipparchikos, and the tract on Horsemanship, and the pamphlet on Revenues. I do not count the Agesilaus (for reasons afterwards to be specified) nor the Apology, which I hold to be spurious.

Into the minutiae of this question I need not here enter, but will reserve its discussion for a footnote. I agree with most modern critics in accepting 371 b.c. ^ as most probably

1 This is Roquette’s view (de Xen. Vit. i. § 6, p. 26 foll.), with which Grote (/T. G, ix. 245, 246) evidently agrees (though in his Plato, iii. 567, he seems to have altered his view). I cannot do better than quote his words. “The interesting description which he himself (Xenophon) gives of his residence at Skillus implies a state of things not present and continuing, but past and finished. Other testimonies, too, though confused and contradictory, seem to show that the Laconian settlement at Skillus lasted no longer than the power of Lacedaemon was adequate to maintain it. During the misfortunes which befell that city after the battle of Leuctra {i.e. 371 B.C.), Xenophon, with his family and his fellow-settlers, was expelled by the Eleians, and is then said to have found shelter at Corinth.” This date is at any rate much nearer the mark than 363-362 B.C., which, unless it is a mere slip of the pen, would seem to be Grote’ s later view, as expressed in his Life of Xenophon, above referred to. ’ ’ Skillus, ” he there says, ’ • the place in which the Lacedaemonians had established Xenophon, was retaken by the Eleians during the humiliation of Lacedaemonian power, not long before the battle of Mantineia ” {i.e. 362 B.C.) Nor again do I follow Curtius (vol. v. Eng. tr. p. 149 ; bk. vii. ch. ii.) when he says, ’ ’ The war between Arcadia and Elis ” (referring to the war of 365 B.C. apparently) ” once more deprived him of a home ; he emigrated to Elis, but about the same time,” etc.

The fullest argument for the date 371 B.C. is given in Roquette’s dissertation, de Xenophontis Vita, He assigns two main reasons for that particular date : —

(i) The Eleians, at the congress, held in the autumn of that year at Athens just after the battle of Leuctra, to which the Athenians invited all who wished to hold to the Peace of Antalcidas, claim that certain cities of the Triphylia (Marganes and the rest, of which they had been robbed in 400 B.C.) should not be regarded as independent [Hell, VL v. 2, in reference to HelU IH. ii. 20), which claim (according to Roquette) implies that they were then recovered.

(2) This recovery could only have taken place when the Laconians were somehow crippled, as they were at the instant of the defeat at Leuctra.

Roquette finds confirmation of his view in th^ following facts, (i) The hostility of Elis to Sparta is z.fait accompli in the winter of 370-369 B.C. — i.e, they are allies of the Thebans on the first Theban invasion of Peloponnese [Hell. VL V. 30 ; Grote, H. G. x. 294). (2) In 368 B.C. the Eleians maintained that these cities had deserted to the Arcadians (Hell. VH. i. 26), which implies that between 400 B.C. and 368 B.c. they had for a season recovered them. (3) Diog. Laertius’s (i.e. Dinarchus’s) phrase, ppaSwdm-uv AaKedaifwvltjy , implying some slackness on the part of Lacedaemon, would be inapplicable after 370 B.C., when Megalopolis was built, and still more so in 369 B.C., when Messenia also was freed ; since, however rapid had been their movements at the latter date, the Lacedaemonians could hardly have relieved the towns in question, being themselves cut off from both the northern roads to the Triphylia.

With this reasoning in the main I agree. I do not think, however, that it follows from the claims put forward by the Eleians at the Athens congress of 371 B.C. that they had necessarily at that time recovered the townships, since the claim was clearly irrespective of any uti possidetis^ or their then condi-

the date of the occurrence, the history of which I will now state in the words of the most ancient authorities. This is what Dinarchus the orator tells us in the pages of Xenophon’s biographer, Diogenes Laertius. “The Eleians marched against Scillus, and through the tardiness of the Laconians (in relieving it) took the place ; at which time his sons made their escape by stealth, with a few of the domestics, to Lepreum (a township farther south in the Triphylia); and Xenophon himself, first to Ells (?),^ and then to Lepreum, where he joined his sons ; and from Lepreum eventually escaped along with them to Corinth, and there settled.” ^

Xenophon is silent in his history of the times about this, as also about much else of larger historical importance. Whether or not he betook himself to Elis ^ (city or district), or for what reason, now or at any subsequent moment, is beyond

tion. It was anterior. Perhaps they had already recovered them : perhaps they only succeeded in their object later. By 368 B.C. apparently they bad again lost them.

^ els rV ”HXii’ wp&repov. This is puzzling. Why should he at such a crisis betake himself to Elis? One would like to substitute “TXiyi’, if only one could find authority for such a name or district “Forest,” or “woodlands ” ; but see below.

2 Diog. Laert. § 9 of Lt/e.

^ According to Pausanias, v. 6, 6.

The Eleian exegetae told the traveller, when he visited the spot five centuries afterwards, that Xenophon had been condemned in the judicial council of Olympia, as being a wrongfiil occupant of the property at Scillus obtained through Laconian violence ; but that the Eleians had granted him indulgence and allowed him to remain. He adds that a short distance fi*om the temple a monument was pointed out, with a statue in Pentelic marble on the tomb, which the inhabitants believed to be of Xenophon. His words are : o2 di ‘HXeiiav i^rfyTjral KOfdcaffdoL re atdis ^KiWovvra ‘HXe^ovj iXeyw, koX ^evotpfavra, 8ti i\ap€ vapd. AaKeScu/xovibjv r^v yrjPy KpiO^vai fikv iy rj ‘OXvfiiriK^ povXy, Tvxf>y’ra Si irapd ‘HXefwv (nrfyvdifMis ddews iv ‘LkCKKovvti oIk^ou. Kal d^ KoX 6X/70V AvuT^pci) Tov Icpod /jj’ij/jt.d TL ideiKPVTO KoX TTJs HePTeXijffip iffri \i0OTOfdas eUCup ivl Tip rdu/xp ’ eXpai d^ airrb ^evoipiaPTos \iyowyiP cl rrpocoiK’ ovpres. But probably Grote is right in his criticism of this story : “As it seems clearly asserted that Xenophon died at Corinth, he can hardly have availed himself of the indulgence ; and I incline to suspect that the statement is an invention of subsequent Eleian Exegetae, after they had learnt to appreciate his literary eminence” (Grote, Plato, iii. p. 568). Or is it p>ossible that there is some truth in the story — that the case was heard and sentence passed, followed by a special indulgence, for whatever reason, granted to the pious intruding foreigner : which indulgence he for many reasons may not have cared to avail himself of? The story in any case is interesting as a tradition.

our discovery. To Corinth clearly he eventually came, and there he once more established himself.

Corinth then we assume to be the scene of Xenophon’s last years. At Corinth we must suppose he finished his literary labours. At Corinth, according to the statement of another ancient authority, “he finished his course.” But there were many years to run yet before the last lap of the race was reached.

At Corinth, 371-354 b.c. circa; Recall, and Service of his Sons in THE Athenian Cavalry, 369 b.c. ; Death of Gryllus, 362 b.c ; Literary Labours, 359 b.c. and onwards ; Old Age and Final Work, 355 b.c. ; Death, 354 b.c. circa.

The years which remain appear to have flowed in general with an even tenor. They are the years of ingathering. One is aware of certain autumnal tints, and an occasional flutter as of sere leaves falling, but they were rich with the fruitage of ripe thought and Uterary labour. It is of that we think rather than of the two or three external incidents which fall within the period. These latter, however momentous as personal experiences, are devoid of complexity, and may be briefly chronicled. The most important of them are the recall of Xenophon from banishment, the mission of his sons to Athens, and the death of Gryllus.

If we are right in our dates and suppositions, Xenophon was past sixty when he found a new home for himself and his family at Corinth. His wife was, we hope, still living ; no one knows. His sons would be young men of about eight or nine and twenty. They had perhaps already seen service,^ oppor-

^ See the passage. Hell. V. iii. 9, in which the historian describes the campaign undertaken after the defeat and death of Teleutias before Olynthus in 381-380 B.C. The authorities despatched the king, and with him, as in the case of Agesilaus’ Asiatic campaign (see above, p. cxv.), thirty Spartans rpidKovra “LirafynaTGiv ’ iroWol dk airr^ Kal tCjv vepiolKuy ideXovTal KoKol Kayadol ijKoKo^dow Kal ^ivoi r(av Tpo(l>ifi<ji)v KaXovfi^pcjv koI v60ol tQv J/irapTLaTihv iidXa e^etSei j t€ Kal tGjp iv t^ ir6Xet KaXwv oi)K dveipoi, Grote (H. G. x. 91) conjectures that Xenophon’s two sons, being educated at Sparta, would come under the category of Tp6(f>ifjL0i, and if either were old enough, he might probably have been among the volunteers to accompany Agesipolis. At this date Gryllus may have been about eighteen, and of an age to serve. For the noble carriage of these young men and their high

tunities for which were not lacking during the last ten or twelve years of their sojourn in the Triphylia, Possibly they were to be found among the ” foster-sons ” of Lacedaemon, who followed the Spartan king Agesipolis against Olynthus in 380 B.C. ” Handsome fellows, and well versed in’ the lore of Spartan chivalry,” we can well believe, they were.

In 369 B.C a rarer chance presented itself to the young men of doing service in behalf not only of Sparta but of their truer fatherland, and in the state cavalry of Athens. The sentence of banishment under which their father lay was rescinded, we may suppose,^ about the same date, and possibly the two incidents are connected as cause and effect The biographer Diogenes Laertius merely tells us^ that “meanspirit, see the description of the ca^ry skirmish in which Gryllus fell before Mantinea, already quoted above ; Hell. VIL v. 17, and below. We may be certain that they knew all about cavalry manoeuvres and horsemanship from their father, whose happiness it was to have sons who shared his tastes and po’haps his most cherished beliefs.

  • We have reason to believe, on independent grounds, that Xenophon was reconciled to his country within five years of the battle of Leuctra. The decree rescinding his exile may therefore have been passed already in 369 B.C., or it may have been a subsequent matter. But whether his sons served their country while their father was still an exile, or only after the sentence of recall was passed, is a minor matter. As a sign and seal of reconciliation, we find the sons serving in the state cavalry from 369 b.c to 362 B.C., and the father addressing his political pamphlet, the Hipparchikos^ to one of the hipparchs of the year, apparently 365 B.C. See next note.

2 On the authority of Dinarchus apparently, or of the orator as quoted in Diocles, ap. Diog. Laeti., op. cit, § 10. The statement of the historian Ister, ap. Diog. Laert., op. cit. § 15, xai ‘Icrrpoj tpn/iirlv avrbv ipvyeip kotA rfr^fffia Ei)/3ot$Xov koX KareXdeTv Kwrit \jHiurfJM toO a^oO, may or may not be correct as r^ards the identity of Eubulus (see above), but is good external evidence to the fact of Xenophon’s recall. The internal evidence of the Nipparchikos — evidently written by a man of mature age, and addressed to the hipparch of the year during an interval of peace {Hipparch. i. 19 ; iv. 6), when there was a prospect of a war with the Boeotians (ib, vii. 3) — points (as Roquette shows, op. cit. ii. 24, pp. 95, 96) to the year 365 B.C. as the date of publication, and is conclusive as to the completeness of the author’s reconciliation with his coimtry. As to Eubulus, it is quite possible that the well-known statesman Eubulus of Anaphlystus may have proposed the decree of recall. Xenophon was not indeed precisely of his colour of politics, since Eubulus was at this date, I suppose, an adherent of Aristophon, and had never favoured Sparta as Callistratus and his friends did. When we come to 355 B.C., however, Eubulus’s views, as the head of the peace party, may possibly have seemed statesmanlike to Xenophon. I regard the Il^pot as the speech or political essay of an old man, written perhaps to order, or to serve a friend, and in behalf of commercial interests, but none the less sincerely. Cf. Isocr. de Pace.

while the Athenians having passed a decree to aid the Lacedaemonians, Xenophon sent his sons to Athens to serve in behalf of the Lacedaemonians,” adding, in a later passage, that according to the historian Ister, the decrees of Xenophon’s banishment and recall were due to the same person, whose name was Eubulus. What is of greater importance to us regarding the matter biographically, is that after so many years of change and counterchange in the domestic and foreign politics of the city, and of her political parties, the moment had at last come in which Xenophon, in the persons of his sons, and by the labour of his pen, might find himself once more functioning like a true-born Athenian, powerful at once in speech and action (Acyctv tc koI Trpdrruv SwaraToyraTos).

Such a happy conjunction of the stars was reached in 369 B.C. ; happy it was, at any rate, for Xenophon, as he scanned the political horizon, and waited for a sign in Corinth. We can easily follow the sequence of events, as we turn over the pages of his own history : the cold shudder which ran through the Athenian senate, seated in the Acropolis, at receipt of the news of Leuctra^ (b.c. 371); the reawakening ambition of the leaders of the Democracy to strike out a more independent policy ; the thought of hegemony ; the retreat of the Spartan reinforcements; the intercession of Jason j^ the summons to a congress at Athens of all who cared to hold to the Peace of Antalcidas; the dissentient Eleians contesting the autonomy of such townships as Marganes and Scillus and the Triphylia;^ the rebuilding of the walls of Mantinea, and the recovery of her civic life in spite of Agesilaus ; the pan-Arcadian movement, and the split of parties at Tegea ; the rival programmes of her demos and her optimates ; the party of Callibius driving out the party of Stasippus ; the intervention on the one side and the other of Mantinea and Sparta ; the cohesions and disruptions of the Arcadian League ; the elective affinities of the different states of Peloponnese ;

^ Hell. VI. iv. 20, tCov dk ‘AdrjvaXbjp if /3ovX^ injyxo^^ ^ dKpov6\€i Kadrjfi^rjj k.t.X.

2 Id. id. 20-24. Note Jason’s Xenophontine argument, koL 6 dchs dk, Cjs foiK€f iroWdKLS x’^P^^ ’^^^ y^^ fUKpods fieyaXods rroKaPf Toifs dk /te7aXoi>s fiiKpods, and see below, Anab. III. ii, lo, p. 154.

® lb. V. 1-3, for the congress at Athens, and the dissent of the Eleians.

the fierce party politics; Arcadian Orchomenus refusing to join the League in hatred of Mantinea ; the Argives biding their time ; the abortive attempt to try conclusions with Mantinea on the part of Agesilaus during the mid-winter of 370 B.C. ;^ the fateful spring of 369; the Thebans joining the Arcadians, and with them a cloud of northern powers — the Phocians and the Eubaeans, the Locrians and the Acarnanians, the Heracleotes and the Malians, with horse and light infantry from Thessaly, — their objective Laconia; the burning of Sellasia; the enemy encamped near the unwalled city of Sparta itself; the women of Sparta and the sons of Sparta at bay; the hideous nightmare dissolving as the Theban army passed on to Amyclae and across the Eurotas away to Helos and Gytheum; the Spartans offering and dreading to arm their helots ; a new horror ; the four faithful allies — the men of Phlius, the men of Corinth, the men of Epidaurus and Pellene ; ^ the restoration meanwhile of Messene,’ the autonomy of which ancient state, now suddenly revived, will become the keystone of the pan-Boeotian policy of the great Theban statesmen ere long ; and so we are brought to the moment when, as we picture to ourselves, there was a break in the storm-clouds overhead, through which a ray of joyous sunlight shed itself on the veteran historian, seated in his study at Corinth, and waiting for a sign.

It is no part of my intention at present to attempt to estimate the political position of Xenophon either as a citizen or as a historian of the time. To do so would lead us too far afield, and involve us in the discussion of deeper matters concerning the literary and philosophical standpoint of our author, which may fitly be postponed for future consideration.^

^ HelL VI. V. 3-21, for the incidents in Peloponnese till the winter of 370 B.C.

^ lb. lb, 22-32, for the incidents of the first Theban invasion in 369 B.C.

^ Xenophon omits to mention the founding of pan-Arcadian Megalopolis and the restoration of Messene at the moment, but refers to both later on. Hell, VII. V. 5 ; and VII. i. 27, 36.

  • I hope in my last volume to offer a few remarks on Xenophon’s literary quality and position in the evolution of thought and feeling — in a word, his spiritual quality. But such observations clearly should stand as the epilogue rather than as the prologue to the piece. In my next volume we shall be directly brought face to face with the problem of Xenophon’s position as one

If, however, we wish to discover certain political leanings of Xenophon at this particular period of his life, we cannot do better than study the sentiments which he puts into the mouth of the Athenian orator Callistratus (the head of the anti- Theban or ” Laconising ” party at Athens between the years 378 B.C. and 361 B.C.) when sent with Callias and Autocles to Sparta before the battle of Leuctra in 371 b.c.;^ or again, of the Philiasian envoy Procles in his address to the Athenian ecclesia in 370 b.c.^ It was that speaker’s eloquence which carried away the feelings of the Assembly, so that the arguments of the opposition fell on deaf ears, and the resolution was passed to aid Sparta with a levy en masse ; and for this object Iphicrates was chosen general, 369 b. a If it was a satisfaction to Xenophon to send his sons back to Athens at such a crisis, the conduct of the campaign was not altogether to his taste as a military critic. The blunder of Iphicrates — since, in spite of his great ability as a general, he seems to have committed a blunder in the handling of his cavalry — made a deep impression on Xenophon, and served him for illustration in his

of the Attic historians. Meanwhile I commend to the notice of my readers Mr. Freeman’s essay, “The Historians of Athens,” Hisiorical Essays, 2nd series.

1 For 371 B.C., see Hell. VI. iii. 10-17. Callistratus’s is the third speech, and is skilfully juxtaposed so as to form a climax to the bracing home-truths of Autocles and the professional platitudes of the Dadouchos Callias. Callistratus admits that Athens and Sparta have both made grave blunders as imperial and rival states. But sweet are the uses of adversity. One need not continue rivalry to the bitter end. It is possible to take the pitcher once too often to the well, dXXd \Lh\pf ovd* iKclvovs fy&rye ivawQ tiriycs dyuviffTcd yevdfievoi koI yeviKi^K6r€s ifdrj iroXKdKii Kol b6^€Uf ^ovres oUrws ^XoveiKoOffiv, CxTTC oi> rrp&T€poy ira^<rovTax irplv &v rp^riOipres t^p H^K-qciv KaToK^ffCMriy, oW^ ye tCjv KVpeurQv cXrives ad iikv tv ti kicLT&xitxn irepl SiirXaa’iujv Kv^tilrova’iy. opQ ykp Kal rwv toio^wv roif$ ifKdoxK &ir6povi irayrdiraffi yiyyo/xivovs. The athlete may descend once too often into the arena. The gambler may go on doubling the stakes till he finds himself penniless, A xM ’^^ ^Amis bpCbvrai eh fi^v ToiovToy ayCjya /iiyS^irore KaTocrnjycu, drr* ij vdyra Xa^eiy fj vdyr’ diro/3a\6?v, ^(os di Kal ippdjfJieOa Kal e^vxovpxv L\ovs dWi^Xois y€v4<r6ai. Let us pause in time and shake hands, before our stock of strength is spent, and our luck exhausted. So shall we through you, and you through us, attain to an unprecedented height of power throughout Hellas, o(h-w ydp -^/xets r’ Af 5t’ ^/ias KoX iffieU di iifias Uti fiel^ovs ij rbv trapeKSbyra xp^^oy h t^ ‘EXXddi dyaarpe- </>olfi€da,

2 For 370 B.C., see Hell. VI. v. 38-48, ivl W ro&rtfi (Cleiteles of Corinth) dviarrj UpOKXrjs ^Xidaioi koX elirey, “0 rt /x^y, c& Aydpes ^AOrpfdioi, K.r.X,

pamphlet on the cavalry general’s duty so often referred to.^ This is how he speaks of it.

The professed object of Iphicrates was to cut off the retreat of Epaminondas and the Thebans returning homewards in the winter of 369 b.c. This, intentionally or not, he failed to do. The historian was well posted in Corinth to watch the tactics of both parties. As the enemy withdrew from Lacedaemon Iphicrates fell back with his Athenians on Corinth. (He lays his finger sharply on the Athenian general’s next move.) Whilst watching on Oneion to intercept the enemy’s retreat, he allowed him free exit by the magnificent side route of Cenchreae; and then in his desire to discover whether the Thebans had passed Oneion, he must needs send the whole of his Athenian and Corinthian cavalry in force on scouting duty, when a handful of troopers would have served the purpose of a reconnaissance quite as well as the larger body. In case of need they would have had a far better chance of hitting upon a suitable road and falling back leisurely. It was the height of folly to advance a force at once so large and yet inferior to the enemy. It was inevitable, owing to the extent of ground they covered, that they should be involved in all sorts of difficulties, and the result was the needless sacrifice of twenty troopers. The Thebans meanwhile were past and gone, and no one said them nay. With this criticism should be compared an admonitory note addressed to the cavalry general ^ some four years later. Probably both

^ See Hell. VI. v. 51, 52, tl yJkv odp &\o tl koKQs iffrparliyrja-eVf oiJ yj/^ta ’ iK€iva fuivToif A iv ry XP^V ^Kclvifi ^irpof c, vdvra evplffKuj t4 fihr fidrTjVf rdi, d^ Kal dav/j^ptas rreirpayiUva airrtp ’ iwixcipi^ffas fiJtv ydp ^vKdrrew iirl t<J ‘Ovelcpy K.T.X.

^ Hipparch. viii. lo foll. ?rt hk ^o{\ofiau inrofiviiffai koX rdde v\dTT€<rOou clffl ydp TiveSf ot trav fibf tuxriv iirl toiVovs, &p Slv otuprcu Kpelrrovs clvcu, TTOLin-diraffLv d<T0€V€i 5wd/JLei l^pxovraif Cxrre rroKKdKLi (iradov A (p6PT0 iroi’^ffeuf ’ &rav d* iirl ro&rovs S>v tiv (raQs MaTiavrai ^rrovi 6vt€s, troffav oarjv Slv ^x”’<^* Sjupa/uv dyovfftp. ^c») di ^fu XflV^^”^ TOPairrla To^huv voietv, ^rav fjukv KparT^aeiy olbfxevoi dyy, fJt^ €ld€(r$ai ttjs 5w(£/ews, 8<rrpf dp ixv '''^ 7^/> TroXif viKcuf odS4vi vuyjroTe fierafJiiXeiay rrapiax^y- ^Toy di tois irokif KpelrTwriv iirixcLp^ Kcd irpoyiyvdxTKTif &n Toiii<TavTa 6tl dp bivrfrai €VKTiov iffrlPf els rd roiavrd ifyi^fu TToXd KpeiTTOP eTvai dXlyovs i} Trdvra^ Trpoirdyciv, roifs /jUvtw, drreiXey/iiyovs Kal tinrovs koX dpdpas rods Kparlffrovi ’ toiovtm ydp 6vt€S koU TrotTJaaL dv ri kqlI v7rox(>>pv<Tcu d<r(pa\4(rT€pov dv d^vaivTO. 6Tau 8i irpds toi)j KpeLrTovs irdpras TTpoff ay ay ibv d’irox(‘>p€iv /3oi)\i;Tat, dj^dyKij roiJy fiiv ivl rGnf ^paSwdrcop tiririav d\l<rK€s 5^ Kal 5t* dnnr€lav vlirTetv, rods 5^ Kal $id 5v<rxco/)fas

passages were penned about the same time, and serve amongst many others to show the undiminished interest which the old cavalry officer continued to feel in his favourite branch of the service.^

That the sons of Xenophon were present on the above occasion is, of course, not absolutely certain; but, if the biographer is to be relied upon, they probably were. They may also have shared in one or more of those exploits which their father recounts in his list of the valorous deeds of the men of Phlius — as, for instance, when their knights and a picked body of hoplites, aided by a squadron of Athenian cavalry, repelled an attack of the Arcadians and Argives ” at the passage of the river” (eirl ry SLaPaa-ei rov Torafiov) apparently in 368 or 367 B.c.,2 or again under the Athenian general Chares. The admiration of the historian for this little state, the neighbour and ally of Corinth, is highly characteristic, and the manner in which he introduces the story of her prowess as an episode worthy of record is remarkable. Historians,^ he tells us, are ever prone to expatiate upon the great deeds of the great powers, whereas it seems to him a higher duty to bring to light a long list of valorous achievements wrought by some single petty state. There were features physical and historical peculiar to this particular little state of Phlius which tended to rivet his attention to it — its proximity to Corinth, its steadfast loyalty to the Laconian alliance at

dTroXafipdyeadoL* xal yiip woktv r&irov x^^^^^” cOpcTy otov 6jf tis cCfatro, K.T.X, For other criticisms of Iphicrates of a more laudatory character, sec Hell. IV. viii. 36 foll. ; VI. ii. 32 ; id, 39.

1 See especially Hipparch. ix. for various reforms which he proposes to introduce into the state cavalry as to the admixture of a foreign element — e.g. eight hundred citizens and two hundred foreigners at Athens — and his illustration from Laconian reforms (since Leuctra, when their cavalry was wretched, Hell. VI. iv. 11) ; also as to the introduction of A^iriroi, light infantry, among the cavalry, Hipparch. v. 13 ; and an improvement in the arm. He would like to introduce tA KpaifiXva d6o iraXrd, after the fashion of the Persians, instead of the long 86pv KafidKivov ; Horsemanship, xii. 12 ; cf. Cyrop. VII. i. I, and Hell. III. iv. 14, a personal experience. See above, p. cxiv.

’ See Hell. VII. ii. 10, and id. 20, in connection with the Athenian general Chares.

    1. id. 1, Sfjuos 5k dieKapripow iv ry cvfifiaxi^ » dXXA y^p rOv fihf fjLeydXwv v6\€<ay ct rt KaXbv iirpa^aVj AirajfTes oi ffvyypa^ts fU/jufrjyTai ’ ifwl di 5oK€i Kcd et TLS fUKpbi, 9r6Xis odira TroXXd koX Kokk (pya diaTriirpaKTaif frc fiaWop d^ioy ettfox dwoipalveip.

the present crisis, the chivalry of its citizens, their bravery, generosity, and religiousness. But even so, there is a warmth of tone in the chronicle of their doughty deeds which seems to point to some close personal relationship. There is no proof of this ; yet, as we recollect, the old family soothsayer, Eucleides,^ came from Phlius.

In the year 366 b.c. incidents occurred ^ which make it intelligible to us why Xenophon, even if free to return to take up his abode permanently in Athens or the neighbourhood of Athens, may well have chosen to continue his residence in Corinth. The fact is that from this date onwards, and for many years, Corinth was much the quietest place for a student and non-combatant to live in ; and at this period of life, if ever, Xenophon had his hands full of literary work of all sorts. His practical energies were satisfied, as already suggested, by the composition in behalf of his native city of those political tracts which I have used so freely for the purpose of biographic illustration. I believe that he never migrated from his home in Corinth, and for the reason suggested; but it is more than likely that he was often in Athens, the glitter of whose temples was visible from the lofty Acropolis of Corinth, and whose streets and squares were dear to him.^ Perhaps he was there for weeks at a time, or months, or even years, but ” stranger-loving Corinth,” as the biographer’s epigram has it, had received him in the day of need, and to her fostering arms he clung. Here a student of history and politics might gaze at the shifting scenes of the complicated drama now enacting without being called upon to play a part himself. The various vicissitudes of states and parties would proceed, but the philosopher would not himself be caught into the vortex of political life. Governments would rise and fall ; the great man might become, like Jason,* greater and most

^ See abdve, pp. Ixxii., xcv., and below, p. 325.

2 See Hell. VII. iv. 6-1 1, and note 2, next page ; and cf. for the situation of the moment Isocr. Archidamos ; Jebb. Att Or, ii. 193.

’ See Revenues, i. 4, for the architectural beauty of the city, iC(£XX((rTot yukv vaolf KdWurroi 8^ ^(Ofwl , , . e^peiriaraTa d^ Geots d^dX/uara, and Hipparch, ch. iii. for topographical details in connection with the Panathenaic procession and other To/ival, There is a strong flavour of Attic life in such passages. The local colouring, at any rate, is vivid and very pleasing.

  • See, for Jason’s rise and fall, especially Hell, VI. iv. 27-32 ; and for the

great, and at the height of his power fall by the knife of an assassin, but the working out of the divine purpose would only be clearer to his religious consciousness. Tyrants like Euphron and Lycomedes might flourish for a season and be swept to their doom, his heart might be touched, but the hand of the artist would not falter in its portraiture ; the chronicler of tragic incidents would depict and criticise and point his morals, as the spirit moved him, with reserve and dignity. He might be tempted to throw down his pen in despair at the confusion worse confounded which seemed the sole result of the battlefield of Mantinea,^ but the wave of its storm would not come nigh him. He could still console himself with his great philosophical romance and his minor scientific treatises. It was as the result of a series of such political vicissitudes ^

artifice of style, /i^as fui^iov /i^i<rroj, cf. Hell. VI. v. 47, KciXbv KiXKiov

^ See the concluding words of the Hellenica, VII. v. 27, “where it was expected that one or other of these fell combatants would rule an empire, there set in once more confusion worse confounded (not an i.pxht b^t worse anarchy),” and my remarks in the volume of essays already referred to, “Hellenica,” p. 383.

2 Hell. VII. i. 39 foil, (i) The state congress at Thebes had proved a failure. None of the powers could be got to sign a rescript obtained from the king at Susa the year before (Hell. VII. i. 33 foll.), securing a common peace on the basis of the autonomy of Messene and the nuUification of the navy of Athens. {2) The Thebans had their hands full in Thessaly. (3) Whilst the armed force of Athens under Chares was occupied in Argolis, the town of Oropus was snatched from her by refugees from Eretria. Chares was ordered home, but as soon as his back was turned the Arcadians and Thebans recovered the port of Sicyon, which was a severe blow to Athens. None of the allies would lielp her (Hell. VII. iv. 1). She was forced to put Oropus into the hands of Thebes till the rival claims could be arbitrated upon (Hell. VII. iv. 2). (4) Lycomedes thereupon seized the opportunity of negotiating a peace with the Athenians, indignant at their isolation ; and so it came about that at one and the same moment Athens was in league with Sparta and her enemies the Arcadians, whilst the Arcadians themselves were in league with Thebes and her enemies the Athenians. But that was not the end of the matter. (5) On the motion of Demotion it was proposed to append as a rider to the Athene- Arcadian peace an injunction to the generals to secure Corinth to the Democracy (Hell. VII. iv. 4, 5) : clirbvTOi bh AfjfioTUovoi iv rf di^fup rCsv k!dt\v(d{av ws 7\ yhf irpbs roifs ‘Apxddas ^iX^a iraXcDs a’drip SokoIti Trpdrrea’dcu, ToTs fJuhroL ffTparriyois Tpo<rrd^ai iri xp^^^ otws koX Kdpivdos crya J T(p di^/Mp TiavA9rfvalu)v’ dKo6<ravT€s d^ ravra ol KoplvOioi … /c.r.X. (6) The Corinthians getting wind of their intention, promptly but in the civilest manner sent away all Athenian troops from their garrisons, and when Chares appeared with his fleet in the harbour of Cenchreae, refused him anchorage (Hell. VII. iv- 5)* (7) Then by a stroke of diplomacy they secured the treaty of neutrality

that Corinth, with her subordinate sister states Phlius, Epidaurus (and Pellene ?), had by a stroke of diplomacy secured to herself (in 366 B.C.) in the midst of the general confusion a position of comparative security. With the permission of Thebes, the consent of Sparta, and the tacit acquiescence of Athens, these states had bound themselves by a self-defensive treaty of neutrality. The oaths were taken at Thebes, since with Thebes they had hitherto along with Sparta been at war ; and Corinth at all events not only continued to keep at peace with all the world for many a long day, but was strong enough to remain unmolested.

We pass on to the year 363 and the incident so often referred to — the death of Gryllus, whom we assume to be the elder of the Dioscuri. He was killed in the cavalry skirmish the day before (or possibly a day or two before) the battle of Mantinea itself. Xenophon has himself passed an encomium on the gallant and unselfish behaviour of the Athenian cavalry, who, to save the sheep and cattle, children and old folk, still outside the walls of the city, rode out at the urgent petition of the townsmen, after a long march and without breakfasting, and achieved their object..^ It was in this engagement, probably, that Xenophon’s son fell. He fought so manfully and was so much beloved that it is easy to understand how the story came to be invented that Epaminondas had fallen by the

above referred to (id. 6-10). After various negotiations the Thebans, as Xenophon tells us, finally offered the Corinthian envoys alliance, which, as implying war with their former friends, was refused. They had come, they said, prepared to swear to an equitable peace ; and the Thebans, admiring their staunch loyalty to old friends in the face of danger, conceded it {(rvv€X(^fyfl<J’av aifTois Kal ^Xtao’fots koX tois iXOovffi fier* airriav els BiJjSas t^v eify^vrjv i (Jre ^X^‘v tV iavTuof iKiiffTovs). I cannot but think that the historian in his heart approves of this whole arrangement, and he certainly does justice to the Thebans. As to the conduct of his friends the Phliasians and Corinthians, he might have said precisely what Archidamus the son of Agesilaus is made to say by Isocrates in the composition so named (Isocr. Or. vi. , Arckidamos, § 91), which purports to be spoken at a particular stage of the negotiations in 366 R.C., during a debate at Sparta on the Theban proposal. ” Epidaurus, Corinth, Phlius, may without reproach prefer safety to honour : Sparta cannot.” * ’ Even, however, if we were utterly forsaken I should be ashamed to give up Messene” (ib. § 70). So Xenophon, of the Spartans on the same occasion: aOroL 5* iifxtaav TroXefioOvTes Tpd^eiv &n Slv rif Qef i\ov J • {ftfy^eaOai 5^ oOS4woT€ ifv wapbi. TUP var^pwv irapfKa^ov Meaa-T^vriy ra&rrfs (TTCptidrjvai. ^ See Curtius, H. G. iv. 484.

hand of Gryllus, as represented in a famous picture.^ The loss of this young man signifies, of course, but a drop in the cup of collective pain ; nor was the particular pain itself without its anodyne, since the youth had died nobly. There is a pretty fragment of a letter among the Xenophontine epistles preserved in Stobaeus, which no one will hold to be genuine, but the sentiment of it is well conceived, and seems to fall from the lips of Xenophon. It is addressed to Soteira, who may be supposed to be the wife or sister of Gryllus. ” Blessed then is Gryllus, blessed amongst those who chose not length of days but a life of virtue ; blessed is he, although God granted to him but a brief space of years ” {fjMKapios odv 8^ TpvXXos koI ootls ov

TO /I’qKUTTOV iXofievos Tov pCov, TO Sc ^€Ta dperrjs, koi ci Ppa^v

ol €&i>K€v alCiva 6 Bcds).^ This is how Diogenes Laertius recounts the matter. He is inaccurate in details, but the tale itself deserved to live. “Diodorus came safely out of the battle without having wrought any conspicuous deed. He had a son born to him whom he named after his brother. Gryllus was serving in the cavalry ; it was the battle of Mantinea, and he fought valorously and was slain, as says Ephorus in chapter xxv. Cephisodorus was in command of the Attic horse, and Hegesileos was general. It was in this battle that Epaminondas fell.^ Meanwhile, as the story goes, Xenophon was engaged in offering sacrifice ; the chaplet was upon his brow when they brought him news, saying, ‘Your son has fallen,’ whereupon he removed the chaplet ; but as the messengers added * nobly ’ he replaced it on his head, shedding, as others have mentioned, no tear, but only uttering the words ii^Lv OvrjTov y€y€vv7fKm, (I knew my child was mortal).” But of this matter enough. To pass on a few years. The autobiographical passage penned by Xenophon in 359 B.C.*

^ Painted by Euphranor. See Pausan. VIII. xi. 6 ; IX. xy. 5 ; Ephor. ap. D. L. ii. 53 ; Plut. de Glor. Athen. ii. 346. The real slayer, according to Dioscorides ap. Plut. Ages. 35, was the Spartan Anticrates (Machaerion).

’ Epp. frag, e Stob. 9.

’ Epaminondas fell in the battle itself, as every one knows. It is doubtless a mistake to suppose that Gryllus fell actually in the same battle. The Athenian cavalry, as we learn from Xenophon himself, scarcely came into action. Nothing at any rate is said of any loss sustained on their part, which, if Gryllus had fallen on that day, would be truly astonishing.

  • HeU. VI. iv. 37, tCjv Se raCra Trpa^dvTuv (the assassins of Alexander of

(which has been more than once referred to) brings us back to the writer’s study ; and now, if ever, we must picture him hard at work finishing and revising, and perhaps superintending the editing of various works. How these labours were performed, and who helped him in them, we cannot say. Perhaps some member of his family, his son or a grandson, or a favourite slave or freedman, played the part of amanuensis. Perhaps works already on the stocks were now finished ; perhaps later and fuller editions of old works, with notes and emendations and appendices, were now being made ; whilst others were still shaping themselves in his brain or upon his lips. One may almost overhear the author dictating to his secretary, who is taking down the sentences. This is not the place to press the inquiry into his manner of composition further.^ I content myself with the suggestion conveyed in the above picture. If correct, it might perhaps explain certain puzzles in connection with many of the Xenophontine writings, as we possess them (his repetitions, and so forth), which are familiar enough to the critical student Perhaps this alter ego^ of whom we seem to be aware, is no grandson . editor,^ nor yet a trader in false wares crudely imitating the writer’s mannerism, but simply the voice of the old man himself going over the old ground, and enunciating in season (or, it may be, out of season) wise saws and solemn instances, the inveterate convictions of a lifetime. If the saws are somewhat pedantic at times ;^ if the amiable didactic air has grown

Pherae) Ax/x o5 55e 6 X670J iypd(f>€TO Turi4>cvoi irpeap&raTos &v rCav iSek^v tV <ipxV c^X^’ Por the date of the occurrence see above, note 2, p. briL

^ It seems to me certain that, if the Cynegetica was a work of his youth (and, doubtless, it is instinct with a certain youthful fervour, as Cobet has said, Mnem. 7, 422, N. L. 774, as of one Ovftoetdovs re Kal ipuyriKov), the author re-handled it in his old age. The Lac. Pol, seems also to have been rehandled ; so too the Memorabilia perhaps, the Cyropaedia^ and the Oeconomic.

^ See above, in reference to the Oeconomic. It is the opinion of many critics that Xenophon’s grandson (the Xenophon of the dvoaraalov \6yos) perhaps edited his grand&ther’s works, and interpolated them. See above. It should be borne in mind that the very existence of this grandson is based upon a mere conjecture, however acute, of Grote (ff. G. ix. 246 note i). It is remarkable what use the critics have made of him. He has proved a very detis ex machina for solving all sorts of bibliographical difficulties.

’ It looks as if Xenophon had in his later years gone to school once more, and taken Isocrates as his model. His style, naturally so simple, appears to

k

upon him ; if he moralises overmuch, we ought not to mind. His heart is still as sound as ever, and his voice was certainly never sweeter than in some of his later works. As I have elsewhere observed,^ we seem to be listening to a sweettongued talker, a wise man and a good, whose style reminds us of the Vicar of Wakefield In spite of his sage talk, he presents to us the appearance of a practical man, who has seen men and manners, and tasted wisdom at the fountain-head. Nothing is pleasanter than to sit by and listen to his reflections, somewhat loosely and yet pretentiously delivered

I have already expressed my conviction that the tract on the Revenues ^ is the latest of his works, and that this essay was written, as I take it, to please a friend, but with absolute sincerity, and from the point of view of commercial interests. It was not penned till 355 B.C., when, probably, the writer was over seventy-five years of age, and within a year of his death.

The limits of this sketch do not permit me to dwell on the many points of biographical interest to be discovered in this and the other minor works of Xenophon, replete as these all are with illustrations of the writer’s personal qualities — his religiousness and his moralising vein, his belief in the virtue of sport and athleticism, his economic bent,^ his strategic and scientific interests, his kindliness to slaves and animals,^ his appreciation of the duties of a good father^ and a good citizen — his pride in Athens underlying all.®

I will content myself with but two instances among many. The first passage is from the Hipparchikos^ and was penned,

have become, sometimes pleasantly and sometimes painfully, artificial. Apart from which, he has suffered much from editors and interpolators.

^ See my essay in ” Hellenica,” pp. 343, 344.

’ As is proved, I think, by internal evidence. Apparently it was intended for a speech, or to be read as a speech, on some financial debate in the Senate at Athens. The friend for whom it was written may have been Eubulus himself, or a supporter of his. For the policy advocated cf. Isocrates, de Pace. If the writer of this tract was not Xenophon himself, it was certainly some one who had thoroughly caught his manner, and thought as he did on most matters.

’ I have already referred to Cyrop. VIII. ii. 5, a passage worthy of Adam Smith.

  • See Cyneg. v. 24, 29, 33, passages which remind one of Gilbert White, Michelet, and Charles St. John. » Sec Cyneg. i. and xii.

8 See Revenues, i. ; v. 10 ; Hipparch. ; de R. Eq. passim.

perhaps, in the year 365 b.c., before his son Gryllus died. The other may be the very last words he wrote before death summoned him also. Both have this biographic quality in common, that the writer relapses into an ancient mood “of mind, and, in the second of them, even into an ancient manner of expression. In the former he is apologising for what may seem to his readers the too frequent iteration of his favourite phrase, crvv S€(^ (God granting). This is what he says : ” If the repetition of the phrase throughout this treatise, * Act with God,’ surprises any one, he may take my word for it, that with the daily or hourly occurrence of perils which must betide him, his wonderment will diminish ; as also with the clearer recognition of the fact that in time of war the antagonists are full of designs against each other ; but the precise issue of these plots and counterplots is rarely known. To what counsellor, then, can a man apply for advice in his extremity save only to the gods, who know all things, and forewarn whomsoever they will by victims, or by omens, by voice or vision ? Is it not rational to suppose that they will prefer to help in their need, not those who merely seek them in time of momentary stress and trouble, but those who, in the halcyon days of their prosperity, make a practice of rendering to heaven the service of heart and soul ? ” ^

The concluding paragraphs of the J^evenues run as follows, and read as if the speaker were recalling an experience of his early manhood : ” Yet if none of these proposals be impracticable or even difficult of execution ; if rather by giving them effect, we may conciliate further the friendship of Hellas, whilst we strengthen our own administration and increase our fame; if by the same means the People shall be provided with the necessaries of life, and our rich men be relieved of expenditure on war ; if with the large surplus to be counted on, we are in a positiori to conduct our festivals on an even grander scale than heretofore, to restore our temples, to rebuild our forts and docks, and to reinstate in their ancient privileges our priests, our senators, our magistrates, and our knights ; — surely it were but reasonable to enter upon this project speedily,

1 Hipparch, ix. 8, 9 ; and for the harking back of thought see Mem, and Symp, passim.

SO that We too, even in our own day, may witness the unclouded dawn of prosperity in store for our city.

” But if you are agreed to carry out this plan, there is one further counsel which I would urge upon you. Send to Dodona and to Delphi, I would beg you, and consult the will of Heaven : whether such provision and such a policy on our part be truly to the interests of Athens both for the present and for the time to come ? If the consent of Heaven be thus obtained, we ought then, I say, to put a further question : whose special favour among the gods shall we seek to secure with a view to the happier execution of these measures ? And in accordance with that answer, let us offer a sacrifice of happy omen to the deities so named, and commence the work; since if these transactions be so carried out with the will of Gk)d, have we not the right to prognosticate some further advance in the path of political progress for this whole State ?” ^

^ 116poit vi. 1-3. This reads like the peroration to a speech addressed to the Boule in a finance debate (see above, p. cxlvi.) ; and for tlie thought passing through his mind see Mem, and Anab,

Book contents. Previous: Introductory remarks and notes. Next: Anabasis, Book I.

Published: 9 Nov 2026

The Drums of Atlantis 1,000,000-Year Timeline Map

A million years of human history, with the focus on the last 26,000 years.

I spent years cross-referencing the Akashic Records, ancient chronicles, and the most recent discoveries to create this.

This is not another dry schoolbook timeline.

This is a wall-sized visual journey that stretches from the very first sparks of human consciousness all the way to today, revealing civilizations, cataclysms, and hidden chapters that conventional history still refuses to acknowledge.


✨ Every major epoch, lost civilization, technological leap, and spiritual awakening is mapped with stunning clarity. You’ll see connections you’ve never noticed before.

✨ Conversation starter & spiritual anchor: Guests will stop, stare, and ask questions. It turns your space into a sanctuary of forbidden knowledge and wonder.

$25 High-resolution PDF

Get the 1,000,000-Year Timeline Map (PDF)

Instant PDF download. Full refund within 14 days if you are not satisfied.

See what is on the map