Table of Contents
In 1898 a cable-laying vessel, looking for a broken cable between Brest and Cape Cod discovered that the sea-floor (1,609 kilometers) north of the Azores at a depth of (10,171 feet) consisted of high peaks and mountainous valleys. Special sounds dragged along the bottom brought up fragments of vitreous lava which could only have solidified in that particular form under atmospheric pressure; yet they must have been plunged beneath the water shortly after cooling because the process of erosion had not planed down the surface and levelled out the sharp hollows and protuberances of the rock. From this data a few geologists of eminence,25 agreeing about the volcanic nature of this part of the Atlantic bed, have come to the conclusion that there must have been an island such as Plato’s island existing in the Atlantic long after the opening of the straits of Gibraltar.
Lost Atlantis
This conclusion is based on the mountainous character of the ocean bed in the region of the Azores, the volcanic nature of the islands in the ocean depression West of the African-European zone, and the fact that the lava and other volcanic detritus which has been brought up from the ocean bed north of the Azores between Cape Cod and Brest must have cooled quite recently under atmospheric pressure, i.e. above water. According to Termier the Platonian history of the Atlantic is highly probable. Professor Scharff of Dublin also indicates the volcanic nature of the Atlantic islands and states his belief that up to Tertiary times the Azores and Madeira were connected with Portugal; there was in his opinion a south Atlantic continent as well stretching from Morocco and the Canaries southwards towards South America. The northern part remained until Miocene (late Tertiary) times when the Azores and Madeira became isolated from Europe and the north and south Atlantic became joined. More recently Scharff stated his belief that the Atlantic islands were reunited with the Old World in the early part of the Ice Age when man, who had already appeared in western Europe, could have reached these islands by land. Professor Gregory thinks that the Atlantic islands are fragments of an Atlantic continent into which the Atlas and Alpine ranges were once produced; and Professor Hull characterises the Azores as peaks of a submerged continent which flourished in the Ice Age.
Daniel Wilson on the Azores
Daniel Wilson collected his essays in The Lost Atlantis and Other Ethnographic Studies (1892). In the title essay he rejects the idea of a sunken continent in the Atlantic, though he holds that ancient voyages across the ocean were possible. He discusses the Azores in both respects.
Local upheaval, not a sunken continent
Wilson cites Wyville Thomson and Sir Charles Lyell. In his account the Atlantic basin is very old, and the volcanic islands show local upheaval rather than the remains of a submerged land.
So far from geology lending the slightest confirmation to the idea of an engulfed Atlantis, Professor Wyville Thomson has shown, in his Depths of the Sea, that while oscillations of the land have considerably modified the boundaries of the Atlantic Ocean, the geological age of its basin dates as far back, at least, as the later Secondary period. The study of its animal life, as revealed in dredging, strongly confirms this, disclosing an unbroken continuity of life on the Atlantic sea-bed from the Cretaceous period to the present time; and, as Sir Charles Lyell has pointed out, in his Principles of Geology, the entire evidence is adverse to the idea that the Canaries, the Madeiras, and the Azores, are surviving fragments of a vast submerged island, or continuous area of the adjacent continent. There are, indeed, undoubted indications of volcanic action; but they furnish evidence of local upheaval, not of the submergence of extensive continental areas.
Daniel Wilson, The Lost Atlantis and Other Ethnographic Studies (1892), chapter I, pp. 5-6
Carthaginian coins on Corvo
Wilson links Antilla, an island that Aristotle names as a Carthaginian discovery, with the Azores. He points to Carthaginian coins found on Corvo.
Aristotle applies the name of "Antilla" to a Carthaginian discovery; and Diodorus Siculus assigns to the Carthaginians the knowledge of an island in the ocean, the secret of which they reserved to themselves, as a refuge to which they could withdraw, should fate ever compel them to desert their African homes. It is far from improbable that we may identify this obscure island with one of the Azores, which lie (1,287 kilometers) from the coast of Portugal. Neither Greek nor Roman writers make other reference to them; but the discovery of numerous Carthaginian coins at Corvo, the extreme north-westerly island of the group, leaves little room to doubt that they were visited by Punic voyagers. There is therefore nothing extravagant in the assumption that we have here the "Antilla" mentioned by Aristotle.
Daniel Wilson, The Lost Atlantis and Other Ethnographic Studies (1892), chapter I, p. 9
Donnelly on the Azores as the peaks of a drowned island
In Atlantis: The Antediluvian World (1882), Ignatius Donnelly reads the Azores as the mountain peaks of a sunk Atlantic island, and the lava around them as support for Plato’s account of the catastrophe.
Volcanic peaks and a shoal of mud
He asks what it would mean if the Azores proved to be torn volcanic summits, with great strata of lava descending into the sea, and with the face of the sunken land covered for thousands of miles with volcanic debris.
And suppose we found that the Azores were the mountain peaks of this drowned island, and were torn and rent by tremendous volcanic convulsions; while around them, descending into the sea, were found great strata of lava; and the whole face of the sunken land was covered for thousands of miles with volcanic débris, would we not be obliged to confess that these facts furnished strong corroborative proofs of the truth of Plato's statement, that "in one day and one fatal night there came mighty earthquakes and inundations which ingulfed that mighty people? Atlantis disappeared beneath the sea; and then that sea became inaccessible on account of the quantity of mud which the ingulfed island left in its place."
Ignatius Donnelly, Atlantis: The Antediluvian World (1882), Part I, Chapter V


