Jesus in India and the lost yearsPaul WallisvideoPaul WallisVideosMary MagdaleneVideos Mary Magdalene.maria mary

Jesus in India and the lost years

On The 5th Kind, Paul Wallis sets Kashmir and Ladakh stories beside the church account of Jesus. A monastery tradition names a young traveler from the Levant, called Issa, who stayed in several communities during years the gospels leave blank. A shrine in Srinagar is said to hold Yus Asaf, buried facing east in a Jewish manner, with foot marks read as crucifixion scars, and a death in old age. Wallis calls both local narratives, not physical proof. He says early Christian writers did not share one meaning for life after the cross. Some readers, he notes, treat a short hanging, unbroken legs, and blood from a spear wound as hints of survival rather than a corpse brought back. A journey east was possible, in his view, because sea trade was already busy and the canonical youth is mostly unrecorded. He retells a Russian book from the 1890s, later visitors who claimed the same pages, and a British inquiry the monks refused. Where a death occurred matters less to him than who is allowed to tell it.

Key points

  • Wallis presents Hemis and Rozabal traditions that place a Jesus-like teacher in India, including a grave and a death in old age.
  • He says the grave story clashes with a bodily rising and ascent, while a youthful stay in India need not.
  • He reads Paul and the later gospels as different accounts of what followed the cross.
  • A short hanging, unbroken legs, and blood after a spear are the hints he offers for survival.
  • Busy sea routes and a mostly blank youth, he argues, leave room for travel as far as India.
  • Notovitch, later witnesses, and a hostile British check are his story of unpublished pages, and he says neither side has physical proof.

Topics

Short quotes

And the story goes that he lived in this community until the age of 80 when he died of old age.

Paul Wallis, Paul Wallis on Jesus in India
Photo of Paul WallisPaul Wallis, Paul Wallis on Jesus in India

He is giving the shrine story’s ending, a long life rather than a death at the cross. Watch at 3:47

And I think the gospel writer may be putting a puzzle before us. What does that mean? Do dead bodies bleed?

Paul Wallis, Paul Wallis on Jesus in India
Photo of Paul WallisPaul Wallis, Paul Wallis on Jesus in India

He treats blood after the spear as a riddle the gospel writer may be setting. Watch at 18:04

So yes, it's entirely possible that Jesus could have traveled. He has a 30-year gap in his timeline if we follow the canonical stories.

Paul Wallis, Paul Wallis on Jesus in India
Photo of Paul WallisPaul Wallis, Paul Wallis on Jesus in India

He points to unrecorded decades in the church timeline as room for travel. Watch at 24:15

In the final analysis, what difference does it make whether Jesus died in Jerusalem or in Kashmir?

Paul Wallis, Paul Wallis on Jesus in India
Photo of Paul WallisPaul Wallis, Paul Wallis on Jesus in India

He asks whether the place of death is really the disagreement that matters. Watch at 45:26

Video by The 5th Kind. Watch on YouTube.