Table of Contents
Inspiring Philosophy asks historian Tom Holland what the world would lack if Christianity had never existed. His case, drawn from Dominion, is that secular life and humanism grow out of Christian history, including medieval fights over church power, not out of a neutral gift from Greece and Rome. Marriage is one exhibit. Consent, not a father’s force, became the basis of a union, against older household heads. Roman sexual custom, organized around the man who owned the house, looks alien beside later limits. On slavery he does not claim one verse ends the institution. Reading the cross as the victim overturning the master, and a long argument inside the tradition, is what made abolition thinkable. The modern sense of science, he adds, is a late word on top of an older confidence that a rational creature can study an ordered world. Churches now struggle, he says, because they won and their once strange morals became common sense. If that inheritance had never arrived, the progress people argue about would not be there to finish.
Key points
- Tom Holland argues that Western secular life and humanism grow out of Christian history rather than out of classical leftovers.
- He treats consent, not parental force, as the church’s rule for a valid marriage, against older household power.
- Roman sexual ethics, centered on the head of a house, are part of the contrast he draws.
- Abolition, in his account, comes from Christian moral reasoning even though no single verse bans slavery as such.
- He calls the modern meaning of science a nineteenth-century development with older theological roots.
- His counterfactual is that without Christianity the idea of progress itself would not be there to pursue.
Short quotes
It was consent, not coercion, that constituted the only proper foundation of a marriage.
Tom Holland, What if Christianity never existed
He credits the church with making free consent, rather than family force, the test of a marriage. Watch at 22:41
No word for science existed before the 19th century.
Tom Holland, What if Christianity never existed
He uses the late arrival of the modern word to argue that science is not a timeless category. Watch at 53:15
The problem for churches basically is that they've won.
Tom Holland, What if Christianity never existed
Once Christian morals became ordinary common sense, he thinks churches lost what made them distinct. Watch at 1:10:23
So, if Christianity didn't exist, we wouldn't have progress and so we wouldn't worry about it.
Tom Holland, What if Christianity never existed
His answer to the counterfactual is that the very aim of progress is a Christian inheritance. Watch at 1:19:28
Video by InspiringPhilosophy. Watch on YouTube.