(2) - Crantor believed the story of Atlantis to be a true historical fact.
So much so that he and others even accused Plato of having copied the whole Republic from the Egyptians and of having used the story of Atlantis to demonstrate that the Athenians truly once lived according to that perfect constitution.However the dialogues only "pretend" that the antediluvian Athenians correspond to the inhabitants of the Republic, they are not even presented as perfect and they also perish in the same cataclysm of Atlantis, so this kind of accusation makes no sense to me.Crantor adds that the details narrated by Plato are true and confirmed by the prophets of the Egyptians who report how this story could still be found written on columns in Egypt!
Proclus reports that Crantor took the story as plain history.
In his account Crantor said the Egyptian prophets confirmed it and said it was written on pillars that still stood.
With respect to the whole of this narration about the Atlantics, some say, that it is a mere history, which was the opinion of Crantor, the first interpreter of Plato, who says, that Plato was derided by those of his time, as not being the inventor of the Republic, but transcribing what the Egyptians had written on this subject; and that he so far regards what is said by these deriders as to refer to the Egyptians this history about the Athenians and Atlantics, and to believe that the Athenians once lived conformably to this polity.
Crantor adds, that this is testified by the prophets of the Egyptians, who assert that these particulars [which are narrated by Plato] are written on pillars which are still preserved.
